Executive Summary

Short-term rentals are currently permitted but face significant regulatory scrutiny in Machias, NY. While the town has no zoning laws currently in effect, residents have expressed strong concerns about short-term rental operations, particularly around Lime Lake. The town is actively considering implementing a permit process specifically for 30-day-or-less rentals, especially in the Lime Lake area.

---

Overview: Are Short-Term Rentals Allowed in Machias, NY?

Short-term rentals are currently permitted in Machias, NY, but operate in a regulatory gray area. The town currently has no zoning laws or ordinances in effect, which means there are no explicit prohibitions or requirements for short-term rental operations. However, this regulatory landscape is rapidly changing:

1. Current Status: Short-term rentals can operate legally, but without oversight or permits
2. Resident Concerns: Strong community opposition has been documented, ranking STR regulation as the 13th most important issue among residents
3. Future Regulation: The town is actively developing STR-specific policies and permit requirements
4. Geographic Focus: Particular concern exists around Lime Lake, where residents report issues with STR guests

The town's comprehensive plan explicitly states an intention to "consider a permit process for landowners who short term (30 days or less) rent their properties, specifically around Lime Lake."

---

How to Start a Short-Term Rental Business in Machias, NY

Step 1: Understand Current Regulatory Environment

• No zoning restrictions currently apply to short-term rentals
• Lime Lake area is under particular scrutiny due to resident complaints
• Future regulations are being developed, with permit requirements anticipated

Step 2: Market Research and Location Selection

• Lime Lake area: Exercise extreme caution due to high community opposition
• Downtown/Rt. 16 corridor: Lower regulatory risk but limited tourist demand
• Rural residential areas: Generally more acceptable to community

Step 3: Property Requirements

• Single-family residential properties are preferred by the community
• Multi-family dwellings around Lime Lake are specifically prohibited by future zoning plans
• Property standards: Community emphasizes "curbside appeal" and property maintenance

Step 4: Business Setup

1. Business registration with Cattaraugus County
2. Sales tax registration with NY State for STR operations
3. Liability insurance recommended given community concerns
4. Property maintenance plan essential for community acceptance

Step 5: Guest Management

• Quiet hours and noise control critical for community relations
• Waterway protection around Lime Lake must be emphasized to guests
• Community guidelines should be provided to all guests

---

Required Documents, Permits, Licenses, and Guidelines

Current Requirements (As of 2025)

• Business license with Cattaraugus County
• NY State sales tax registration for transient accommodations
• Property tax compliance verification

Anticipated Requirements (In Development)

Based on the town's comprehensive plan, the following are expected:

1. STR Permit Application

   • Required for 30-day-or-less rentals
   • Particularly focused on Lime Lake area
   • Permit fees to cover administrative costs

2. Permit Renewal Process

   • Regular renewal requirements
   • Compliance verification

3. Revocation Process

   • Permit revocation possible for violations
   • Community complaint-driven enforcement

Property Guidelines

• "Curbside appeal" standards will be enforced
• Property maintenance requirements anticipated
• Noise and behavior guidelines for guests
• Waterway protection measures for lake-area properties

Documentation Requirements

• Proof of property ownership
• Site plan and property description
• Insurance verification
• Emergency contact information
• Guest management plan

---

Specific Regulations: City, County, and State Level

Municipal Level (Town of Machias)

Current Regulations:

• No zoning laws currently in effect
• No STR-specific ordinances currently enacted

Anticipated Regulations:

• STR permit requirement for 30-day-or-less rentals
• Lime Lake area focus with heightened scrutiny
• Single-family residential preservation around Lime Lake
• Property appearance standards enforcement
• Noise and behavior regulations for guests

Policy Directives from Comprehensive Plan:

• Policy Statement 22: Establishes permit process for short-term rentals
• Policy Statement 23: Maintains single-family residential character around Lime Lake
• Strong resident opposition documented to STR operations around the lake

County Level (Cattaraugus County)

General Business Requirements:

• Standard business registration requirements
• Health department regulations for rental properties
• Building code compliance verification

State Level (New York State)

STR-Specific Requirements:

• NY State sales tax collection and remittance required
• Short-term rental registration with NY State (effective 2023)
• Sullivan Law compliance for properties with three or more guest rooms
• Fire safety requirements for transient accommodations

General Business Requirements:

• Workers' compensation insurance for employees
• Unemployment insurance registration if hiring staff
• Professional licensing if required for specific services

---

Contact Information for Local STR Authorities

Primary Contacts

Town of Machias

• Phone: (716) 353-2440
• Email: Not available in provided documents
• Address: Machias Town Hall, PO Box 87, Machias, NY 14101
• Website: www.machiasny.gov
• Primary Contact: Code Enforcement Official
• Note: Town Board oversight for STR regulations

Machias Town Board

• Meeting Schedule: Monthly meetings (specific schedule available through Town Hall)
• Public Comment: Available during regular Town Board meetings
• STR Policy Development: Actively developing regulations as of 2025

Supporting Agencies

Cattaraugus County Planning Department

• Phone: (716) 938-9111
• Website: www.cattco.org
• Role: County-level planning and zoning guidance

Cattaraugus County Health Department

• Phone: (716) 373-8050
• Role: Health regulations for rental properties

New York State Department of State

• Website: dos.ny.gov
• Role: State-level STR registration and compliance

NYS Department of Taxation and Finance

• Phone: (518) 530-HELP (4357)
• Role: Sales tax registration and compliance for STR operations

---

Important Considerations for STR Investors

High-Risk Factors

1. Lime Lake Area: Extremely high community opposition documented
2. No Current Zoning: Regulatory uncertainty during transition period
3. Strong Resident Opposition: 5 survey respondents specifically cited STR control as priority
4. Single-Family Preservation: Town policy to maintain single-family character around Lime Lake

Market Opportunities

1. Rural Tourism: Growing interest in outdoor recreation
2. Lime Lake Access: High demand for lake-area accommodations (with community acceptance challenges)
3. Agricultural Tourism: Potential for farm-stay experiences
4. Proximity to Great Lakes Cheese Plant: New employment center bringing potential guests

Best Practices for Market Entry

1. Community Engagement: Proactive outreach to neighbors and local officials
2. Property Standards: Exceed all appearance and maintenance expectations
3. Guest Management: Strict guidelines and monitoring systems
4. Local Partnerships: Align with local businesses and tourism efforts
5. Regulatory Compliance: Prepare for anticipated permit requirements

Timeline Considerations

• Immediate: Current regulatory environment favors established operators
• Short-term (6-12 months): Permit requirements likely to be implemented
• Medium-term (1-2 years): Full zoning implementation expected
• Long-term: Mature regulatory framework with established enforcement

---

Source Documentation

Primary Source:

• Town of Machias Comprehensive Plan - Final Submission v1.0 042125

Supporting Documentation:

• Machias Planning Committee Information

Related Town Resources:

• Town of Machias Official Website

---

This guide is based on the Town of Machias Comprehensive Plan adopted in April 2025 and reflects the current regulatory environment and community attitudes toward short-term rental operations. Given the active development of STR regulations, investors should maintain regular contact with local authorities for updates on implementing ordinances and permit requirements.