Are Short-Term Rentals Allowed in East Hampton, NY?

Short-term rentals are HIGHLY RESTRICTED and effectively prohibited for commercial operations in East Hampton, NY. The town imposes severe limitations that make traditional Airbnb-style operations extremely difficult and financially unviable:

• Maximum of only 2 short-term rentals (less than 2 weeks) per 6-month period
• All rental properties must be registered with the town's Rental Registry
• Registration number must be displayed in all advertisements
• Violations carry substantial penalties ranging from $3,000 to $200,000+

These restrictions are specifically designed to prevent the commercial short-term rental business model while preserving traditional seasonal rental arrangements for local residents.

How to Start a Short-Term Rental Business in East Hampton

Given the extreme regulatory restrictions, starting a profitable STR business in East Hampton presents significant challenges. However, for investors determined to proceed within this constrained environment:

Step 1: Property Eligibility Verification

Verify Property Status:

• Confirm possession of a valid Certificate of Occupancy
• Ensure property is not owner-occupied with guest room rentals (exempt from registration)
• Verify the property is not being rented to immediate family members (exempt from registration)
• Check that property zoning allows residential rentals

Step 2: Complete Mandatory Registration Process

Registration Requirements:

• Obtain and complete the Rental Property Registration Form
• Complete the Rental Property Self-Inspection Checklist (can be done by owner, licensed architect, engineer, or home inspector)
• Have both documents notarized
• Submit copy of Certificate of Occupancy or obtain Building Department confirmation
• Pay $100 filing fee for 2-year registration term

Step 3: Develop Compliance Strategy

Operational Planning:

• Limit rentals under 14 days to only twice per 6-month period
• Consider focusing on longer-term rentals (14+ days) which have no frequency restrictions
• Ensure Registry Number appears in ALL advertisements
• Plan for regular registration renewals every 2 years
• Maintain detailed records of all rental activities for compliance

Step 4: Ongoing Compliance Management

Continuous Requirements:

• Submit registration updates (no charge) when tenant information, rental terms, or property details change
• Monitor advertising to ensure Registry Number is always displayed
• Maintain adherence to occupancy limits (maximum 4 unrelated persons, 4 cars for non-owner-occupied properties)
• Prepare for possible enhanced enforcement using AI monitoring tools

Required Documents, Permits, Licenses, and Guidelines

Mandatory Registration Documents:

Primary Requirements:

1. Notarized Rental Property Registration Form

   • Available at Building Department (300 Pantigo Place) and online
   • Requires property owner information, property details, rental terms

2. Notarized Rental Property Self-Inspection Checklist

   • Can be completed by property owner or licensed professional
   • Required safety and compliance items

3. Copy of Certificate of Occupancy

   • Original or Building Department confirmation of existing CO
   • Must be on file with Building Department

4. $100 Registration Fee

   • Valid for 2-year registration period
   • No charge for updates during registration term

Self-Inspection Checklist Requirements:

Safety and Compliance Items:

• House numbers visible from street
• Handrails on all stairways
• Properly marked electrical panels
• Working smoke detectors in every bedroom
• Fireplace/wood-burning stove doors and screens
• Pool safety requirements (if applicable)
• Emergency contact information availability

Registration Updates Required (No Charge):

Trigger Events for Updates:

• Change in tenant information
• Modification of rental terms
• Change in number of tenants or bedrooms
• Start of new rental period
• Any other material changes to registration information

New York State Requirements:

State-Level Compliance:

• Short-term rentals defined as stays under 30 consecutive days
• State registration requirement for all short-term rental hosts
• Applicable state and local tax obligations
• Compliance with New York State multiple-dwelling regulations where applicable

Specific Regulations for Short-Term Rentals

East Hampton Town Regulations:

Core Restrictions:

• Maximum 2 short-term rentals (under 14 days) per 6-month period
• Minimum rental period of 14 days for short-term rentals
• No "share houses" or time-sharing arrangements permitted
• Maximum 4 unrelated persons per rental property
• Maximum 4 vehicles at non-owner-occupied rental properties
• Rental Registry Number mandatory in all advertisements
• Registration expires every 2 years with renewal required

Prohibited Activities:

Explicitly Banned:

• Renting properties more than twice per 6-month period for stays under 14 days
• Operating share houses or selling occupancy rights for specific time periods
• Advertising without displaying Rental Registry Number
• Operating without proper registration
• Exceeding occupancy or parking limits
• Renting to immediate family members without registration (though exempt)

Occupancy and Parking Limits:

Quantitative Restrictions:

• Maximum 4 unrelated persons per rental property
• Maximum 4 parked vehicles at non-owner-occupied properties
• These limits apply regardless of property size or bedroom count

Advertising Requirements:

Mandatory Disclosure:

• Rental Registry Number must appear in ALL advertisements
• Applies to online platforms (Airbnb, VRBO, etc.) and traditional advertising
• Failure to include Registry Number carries specific penalties

Enforcement and Penalties:

Registration Violations:

• Failure to register: $3,000-$15,000 fine and/or up to 6 months imprisonment
• Missing Registry Number in ads: $150-$1,500 fine and/or up to 15 days imprisonment
• Daily violation accumulation: Each day of non-compliance constitutes separate violation
• Maximum penalties: Over $200,000 possible for repeated violations

Recent Enforcement Developments:

Enhanced Monitoring (2025):

• Town considering AI software to identify illegal rentals
• Approximately 50% of estimated 2,000 listings are currently unregistered
• Increased enforcement budget allocation
• Potential for hotel/motel tax application to short-term rentals
• Possible fee increases to offset enforcement costs

Exemptions from Registration:

Registration Not Required:

• Owner-occupied properties with 1-2 guest rooms rented
• Rentals to immediate family members (spouse, children, parents, siblings, grandparents, grandchildren)
• Properties with valid Certificate of Occupancy confirmed by Building Department

Contact Information for Local Authorities

East Hampton Town - Primary STR Authority:

Building Department (Rental Registry Administration)

• Address: 300 Pantigo Place, East Hampton, NY 11937
• Phone: (631) 324-4145
• Primary Contact: Handles all rental registry applications, renewals, and compliance
• Services: Registration processing, Certificate of Occupancy verification, inspection coordination

Town Supervisor's Office

• Supervisor: Peter Van Scoyoc
• Email: pvanscoyoc@ehamptonny.gov
• Phone: (631) 324-4140
• Address: 159 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937

Code Enforcement Department

• Phone: (631) 324-3858
• Function: Investigates violations, issues appearance tickets, enforces rental regulations
• Services: Complaint investigation, violation processing, court appearance coordination

Additional Town Departments:

Fire Prevention Bureau

• Phone: (631) 329-3473
• Function: Fire safety inspections, safety code enforcement
• Role: Coordinates with rental registry for fire safety compliance

Natural Resources Department

• Phone: (631) 324-0496
• Function: Environmental compliance, drinking water protection
• Relevance: Ensures rental properties don't impact environmental resources

Highway Department

• Phone: (631) 324-0925
• Function: Parking compliance, address visibility
• Role: Enforces parking limits and house number visibility requirements

Emergency Contacts:

Police Department

• Non-Emergency: (631) 537-7575
• Emergency: 911
• Function: Public safety, noise complaints, disturbance response

Airplane Noise Complaint Hotline

• Phone: (800) 376-4817
• Function: Aircraft noise reporting and resolution

East Hampton Village (Separate Jurisdiction):

Village Hall

• Address: 86 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937
• Phone: (631) 324-4150
• Hours: Monday-Friday 9am-4pm
• Note: Village has separate regulations from Town - verify specific requirements

State-Level Contacts:

New York State Department of State

• Function: State short-term rental registration and tax compliance
• Website: dos.ny.gov
• Role: State-level registration requirements and tax collection

Source Links

Primary Regulatory Sources:

• East Hampton Town Press Release on STR Enforcement
• East Hampton Town Rental Registry FAQ
• East Hampton Village Rental Registry Information

News and Analysis Sources:

• Newsday: East Hampton to crack down on short-term rentals
• WLIW Radio: East Hampton Town looking to use AI to limit illegal rentals
• STR Profit Map: East Hampton Regulations Analysis
• STR Haus: Hamptons NY Airbnb Regulation Guide

---

Investment Recommendation: East Hampton presents an extremely challenging environment for traditional short-term rental investment due to restrictive regulations limiting operations to only twice per 6-month period. The regulatory framework appears designed to preserve traditional seasonal rental arrangements for local residents while discouraging commercial STR operations. Investors should carefully analyze whether the limited rental frequency can generate sufficient returns to justify investment, compliance costs, and regulatory risks. Consider alternative strategies such as focusing on longer-term seasonal rentals (14+ days) with no frequency restrictions, or exploring opportunities in less restrictive nearby markets.