Want to see how Nantucket compares to other top cities in Massachusetts? Explore all city regulations in Massachusetts. →
Nantucket, MA
Challenging To Investors
Local STR Agent
Local STR Agent

Yes, short-term rentals are currently allowed and operating on Nantucket, but the regulatory environment remains complex and evolving. Nantucket operates under state home rule authority and has implemented its own registration and regulatory framework for STRs through Chapter 123 of the Town Code and Chapter 338 of Town Regulations. However, zoning compliance remains a critical legal uncertainty following a 2025 Massachusetts Land Court ruling that found STRs may violate existing zoning code provisions. Despite this uncertainty, the town continues to process STR registrations and enforce its registration requirements while working toward a zoning solution.
Nantucket hosts earn a median $68,526/year with $966 ADR and 56% occupancy.
Top performers pull in $128,902+ per year.
See the full Nantucket market breakdownBefore registering, verify that your property meets all local zoning requirements. Given the current legal uncertainty following the Ward v. Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals case, consult with local zoning authorities to confirm STR use is permitted on your specific property.
Definitions and Eligibility:
Operating Requirements:
Fee Structure (Effective October 1, 2024):
Registration Timeline:
Applies to STRs meeting ALL criteria:
CRITICAL: Following the 2025 Land Court ruling in Ward v. Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals:
Main Town Line:
Short-Term Rental Community Liaison:
IMPORTANT INVESTMENT CONSIDERATIONS:
RECOMMENDATION: Given the current regulatory uncertainty, prospective STR investors should conduct thorough due diligence regarding zoning compliance and consider consulting with local legal counsel specializing in Nantucket land use regulations before proceeding with property acquisition or STR registration.
Next step
Paste any address and get estimated revenue, cash-on-cash return, and comparable STR performance in under 5 minutes. 3 free analyses per day.
Free brief
Revenue data, top neighborhoods, seasonal trends, and the key regulations for Nantucket, Massachusetts in one email.



Nantucket is a small island town and county located roughly 30 miles south of Cape Cod, Massachusetts, sitting in the Atlantic Ocean about 100 miles southeast of Boston. The year-round population hovers around 14,000 residents, though this number swells dramatically during the summer months when seasonal visitors and second-home owners arrive. The island has a distinct character shaped by its cobblestone streets, weathered cedar-shingled homes, and a centuries-old maritime past rooted in the whaling industry. Today it is best known as an upscale summer getaway with a relaxed, walkable atmosphere, abundant beaches, and a downtown full of independent shops, seafood spots, and galleries. It is the sole municipality within Nantucket County and is often paired with the nearby island of Martha's Vineyard as a twin New England coastal escape.
Just off the harbor, the Brant Point Lighthouse is one of the most photographed landmarks on the island, marking the entrance to Nantucket Harbor. Located essentially in town, it is a short walk or quick bike ride from the ferry terminal and downtown wharves, and its small grounds and harbor views make it a favorite first stop for arriving visitors. Although the lighthouse is not open for interior tours, its red-and-white tower and adjacent keeper's house provide a classic New England coastal scene that captures the island's seafaring character.
A short drive or bike ride east of town, the historic fishing village of Siasconset, known locally as Sconset, offers a slower-paced glimpse of old Nantucket. The neighborhood is famous for its narrow footpaths, rose-covered cottages, and a bluff-top walk that runs along the Atlantic toward the Sankaty Head Lighthouse. Visitors come for sweeping ocean views, cliff-top gardens, and the village's handful of small cafés and tea spots, all of which feel a world away from the busier harbor area.
On the western end of the island, the Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge stretches across more than five miles of pristine beach, rolling dunes, and protected maritime forest. Accessible by a long, unpaved four-wheel-drive road (or by guided tour), it rewards visitors with some of the most unspoiled shoreline in southern New England and a chance to spot shorebirds, seals, and the occasional osprey. The refuge's far eastern tip is also home to the Great Point Lighthouse, a working light station that anchors the wild edge of the island.
Back in town, the Nantucket Whaling Museum, operated by the Nantucket Historical Association, sits in a restored 1846 spermaceti candle factory and tells the story of the island's 19th-century whaling heyday. Its signature feature is the skeleton of a 46-foot sperm whale suspended above the main gallery, alongside scrimshaw, ship logs, and period artifacts. The museum is within walking distance of the ferry docks and the surrounding historic district, making it an easy anchor for a day of exploring brick-and-shingle downtown.
Nantucket makes a compelling base for short-term rentals because it combines genuine geographic isolation with a deep bench of activities, from lighthouse-hopping and beach days to a compact historic downtown. The island's limited buildable land, seasonal demand, and strong brand recognition support a robust vacation rental market, while the combination of natural beauty, walkability, and easy ferry or air access from Boston, New York, and Cape Cod keeps occupancy strong through the warmer months and gives owners a clearly defined seasonal cycle to plan around.
Enter an address to get instant revenue potential and comps.