New Castle, PA

  • Overview
  • Performance
  • Listings
  • Buy Box

Key Performance Metrics

Market snapshot

Performance indicators for the New Castle short-term rental market based on reliable data.

Listings

14 / 35

Reliable / Active

Cap Rate

18%

Middle-Earners Gross Yield

Revenue

$27,378

Middle-Earners Revenue

Occupancy

63%

Middle-Earners Occupancy

Home Value

$151,505

Median Home Sale Price

Top Earners

$53,720

Top-Earners Revenue

New Castle

Market Revenue Seasonality

Top Listings

Highest revenue

The highest-performing listings in New Castle.

Loading top listings...

B

Generally Investor friendly

New Castle Regulations

STRs are permitted citywide without caps, but investors must verify zoning, obtain health/safety licensing if renting rooms, and register for state hotel tax and county taxes, creating a moderate but manageable compliance burden.

View New Castle Regulations →

Local STR Agent

STR specialist · New Castle, PA

Trusted Expert
Get Expert Help In New Castle
Free consultation Response within 24h

About New Castle

New Castle is a small city in western Pennsylvania, serving as the seat of Lawrence County. With a population of roughly 21,000, it carries the character of a classic Rust Belt town that has reinvented much of its historic core in recent years. The city sits along the Shenango River and Neshannock Creek, and is best known for its preserved Victorian-era architecture, its starring role in several Hollywood films, and as a gateway to a cluster of state parks in the rolling hills of western Pennsylvania. New Castle lies approximately fifty miles northwest of Pittsburgh, making it a comfortable drive for visitors who want a quieter base than the larger city while still being within reach of major urban amenities.

Just to the west of the city, McConnell's Mill State Park is one of the region's marquee natural attractions. A short drive of about fifteen minutes brings visitors to the namesake nineteenth-century gristmill, the adjacent McConnell's Mill Covered Bridge, and the dramatic Slippery Rock Creek Gorge. The park offers hiking trails, rock climbing, picnicking, and whitewater paddling during releases from the mill's dam, making it a strong draw for outdoor enthusiasts.

About twenty minutes north of town, Moraine State Park surrounds the 3,200-acre Lake Arthur. The lake is a year-round draw, with swimming at the beach, a paved seven-mile loop trail popular with cyclists and runners, and extensive boating and fishing opportunities. In winter, the surrounding trails become cross-country ski routes, giving the area four-season appeal for short-term rental guests.

Within the city itself, the New Castle Historic District showcases an extensive collection of nineteenth-century commercial and residential architecture, and the area has been used as a filming location for movies set in earlier eras. The Hoyt Institute of Fine Arts, housed in a historic mansion, presents rotating exhibitions and art classes that give visitors a cultural anchor in the downtown. Local food spots and the restored Cascade Center on the riverfront add to the small-city atmosphere.

For prospective short-term rental owners, New Castle offers a compelling combination of affordability, a walkable historic downtown, and immediate access to two well-trafficked Pennsylvania state parks. Its proximity to Pittsburgh expands the potential guest pool, while the surrounding natural and cultural attractions give the destination enough variety to appeal to outdoor travelers, film-history buffs, and visitors exploring small-town Pennsylvania alike.

startup landing logo

Copyright © 2026 HomeRun Analytics, Inc

Explore

HomeCountry ExplorerProperty Analyzer

Resources

Market ComparatorRegulationsBlog

Trusted by STR investors in 50+ U.S. states

Built by investors, for investors

STRProfitMap® is a registered trademark of HomeRun Analytics, Inc