Performance indicators for the Nashville short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Nashville.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are allowed only by a Special Exception via the Board of Zoning Appeals (public hearing, ~4–6 weeks) and are constrained by strict 250‑ft/1,320‑ft spacing outside town limits and complaint‑sensitive approvals (see https://local.theoffersheet.com/legal/brown-county-in/). Indiana caps initial permit fees at $150 and prohibits outright bans (IC 36‑1‑24‑13), but the permit hurdle, zoning limits, and revocation risk create meaningful operational constraints for investors.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Nashville, IN
Nashville is a small town serving as the county seat of Brown County, Indiana, with a population of roughly 1,000 residents. Tucked into the rolling, forested hills of southern Indiana, it has long cultivated a reputation as a creative refuge, drawing painters, sculptors, woodworkers, and other artists who operate the galleries and studios that line its walkable downtown. The town is best known as a gateway to Brown County State Park and the broader Brown County wilderness area, and it lies approximately 50 miles south of Indianapolis, the nearest major metropolitan center.
Just a few minutes west of town, Brown County State Park spans roughly 15,000 acres of ridges, hardwood forest, and sandstone bluffs, making it the largest state park in Indiana. Visitors come for horseback riding, mountain biking, hiking, swimming, and fall foliage viewing that draws heavy crowds in October. The park's lodges, cabins, and campgrounds make it a year-round draw, and its proximity to downtown Nashville keeps the two destinations tightly linked in travelers' itineraries.
A short drive southeast of the town center, the T.C. Steele State Historic Site preserves the former home and studio of Theodore Clement Steele, often regarded as Indiana's most celebrated landscape painter and a leading figure of the Hoosier Group. The site, listed on the National Register of Historic Places, includes a restored house, gardens, the Large Studio, and more than five miles of walking trails threading through the woods Steele famously painted. It offers a quiet, art-focused counterpoint to the busier downtown galleries.
Downtown Nashville itself functions as a working art colony. The village's commercial streets are lined with dozens of independently owned galleries, craft shops, antique stores, and family restaurants housed in rustic buildings. Live music spills from several venues, and seasonal events like the Brown County Fall Festival, held each October, transform the town into one of the busiest craft gatherings in the Midwest. The Brown County Music Center, located just outside the village, hosts national touring acts and has become a key evening attraction since opening in recent years.
For short-term rental investors, Nashville offers a compelling combination of year-round tourism, a strong seasonal peak tied to fall foliage, and a destination brand that pairs small-town charm with outdoor recreation. Its location within an easy drive of Indianapolis, Bloomington, and Louisville, combined with the steady pull of Brown County State Park and the local arts scene, supports a diverse visitor base that values both cabin-style stays and walkable in-town lodging.