Performance indicators for the Middleton short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Middleton.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Middleton allows STRs only as accessory uses and imposes strict stay‑day caps (30 days/yr for 1–6‑day stays when not owner‑occupied primary residence; 180 days/yr for 6–29‑day stays), plus occupancy limits, guest/business records, and owner‑operator/association consent. Licensing involves multiple jurisdictions with costly pre‑inspections (DATCP $300; County $535) and ongoing fees (City $100, DATCP $110, County $160), creating a notable compliance burden that constrains operations and deters investors.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Middleton, WI
Middleton is a suburban city in Dane County, Wisconsin, situated just west of Madison, the state capital. With a population of roughly 20,000 residents, it has the feel of a well-established commuter community that still retains a distinct small-town identity, anchored by a walkable downtown, a network of neighborhood parks, and a steady stream of visitors who pass through on their way to and from the Madison area. Middleton is best known for its tidy residential streets, its proximity to Lake Mendota, and as a convenient home base for travelers exploring the Madison region and the wider Driftless Area of southern Wisconsin. It lies only about 6 miles west of downtown Madison, with the state capital easily reached in roughly 15 minutes by car.
A surprisingly popular local landmark is the National Mustard Museum, housed in a cheerful yellow building in Middleton's downtown. The museum traces the history, production, and cultural significance of mustard and houses a vast collection of jars, tins, and memorabilia from around the world. Visitors can sample hundreds of mustard varieties in the gift shop before continuing on their way, and the museum is a frequent stop for curious travelers passing through the Madison area.
Just north of the city center, the Pheasant Branch Conservancy offers more than 500 acres of restored prairie, woodland, and wetland threaded with hiking trails. The conservancy includes a portion of the Pheasant Branch Creek corridor that flows down toward Lake Mendota, and it is a well-loved spot for birdwatching, running, and easy family walks. It sits only a few minutes from downtown Middleton and gives visitors a quick way to step into nature without leaving the city limits.
A short drive east brings guests to downtown Madison, where the Wisconsin State Capitol building anchors a lively district of restaurants, museums, and lakeside paths along Lake Mendota. The Capitol's dome is modeled on the U.S. Capitol and is open for free tours, while the surrounding streets offer farmers' markets, live music, and Big Ten energy from the nearby University of Wisconsin campus, all within about 15 minutes of Middleton.
For a longer day trip, Devil's Lake State Park lies roughly 50 miles to the north, offering dramatic quartzite bluffs, a 360-acre lake, and some of the most popular hiking trails in the Midwest. Travelers can reach the park in about an hour by car, making it a comfortable excursion from a Middleton base.
Middleton appeals to short-term-rental owners because it pairs a calm, residential setting with immediate access to Madison's cultural and culinary scene, while still serving as a comfortable launchpad for exploring southern Wisconsin's lakes, bluffs, and small towns. Its central location, friendly atmosphere, and mix of quirky local attractions and natural escapes make it a flexible and rewarding place to host guests year-round.