Performance indicators for the Fontana short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Fontana.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Short‑term rentals are legal and clearly defined, but licensing requires multi‑state and village approvals, annual inspections, detailed site/floor plans, and insurance. The 180‑day operation cap and parking/stay requirements add operational limits, while the multi‑agency process and fees raise cost and complexity.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Fontana, WI
Fontana is a small, quiet village in Walworth County, Wisconsin, tucked along the western shore of Geneva Lake in the state's scenic southeastern corner. With a population of roughly 1,700 residents, the community has a low-key, residential resort feel, defined less by its own commercial bustle than by its lakefront setting and its proximity to the larger resort town of Lake Geneva. It functions as a peaceful gateway to one of the Midwest's most popular summer and autumn getaways, and it sits about 80 miles northwest of Chicago and roughly 40 miles southwest of Milwaukee, making it a practical weekend escape for residents of both metro areas.
The central draw is Geneva Lake itself, one of the largest lakes in Wisconsin and the focal point of the surrounding resort region. Fontana occupies a stretch of the lake's western shoreline, and visitors come for boating, swimming, fishing, and sunsets over the water. A defining feature of the area is the Geneva Lake Shore Path, a roughly 21-mile public walkway that hugs the entire shoreline and passes in front of dozens of historic estates, making it one of the most recognizable attractions in the region. From the village, the lake is essentially at the doorstep of nearly every property.
Just a few minutes north along the lake lies Big Foot Beach State Park, a 272-acre Wisconsin state park with a sandy beach, picnic areas, hiking trails, and wooded campgrounds on the northeastern shore of Geneva Lake. It is the closest state-park unit to Fontana and a popular spot for day use during the warmer months, located about a ten-minute drive from the center of the village.
The neighboring city of Lake Geneva, just a short drive to the south, offers a denser concentration of restaurants, shops, and the historic Lake Geneva Library and Riviera Ballroom along its main streets. The broader Geneva Lake area also includes smaller communities such as Williams Bay and Walworth, each with their own beach access points and marinas, and visitors willing to venture a bit farther can reach the Yerkes Observatory site in Williams Bay, once home to the world's largest refracting telescope and now a landmark of regional scientific history.
For short-term-rental owners, Fontana's appeal lies in its combination of seclusion and accessibility. The village offers a calmer, more residential alternative to the busier resort town next door, while still placing guests within easy reach of the lake, the surrounding state park, and the restaurants and events of greater Lake Geneva. Its position within a comfortable drive of both Chicago and Milwaukee gives the area a deep, year-round pool of weekend and holiday travelers, and the lake-oriented setting lends itself naturally to the kind of getaway experience that performs well in the short-term rental market.