Performance indicators for the New Wilmington short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in New Wilmington.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs appear permitted citywide under PA law, with no identified New Wilmington licensing, caps, or bans; no state-specific STR permit or quota, only standard sales/occupancy tax compliance. Risk remains around unknown local taxes (Lawrence County/borough) and potential future ordinances requiring monitoring.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · New Wilmington, PA
New Wilmington is a small borough in Lawrence County in western Pennsylvania, home to roughly 2,400 residents. The community is best known as the seat of Westminster College, a private liberal arts college affiliated with the Presbyterian Church, and the borough carries the unhurried, walkable character of a classic small college town. Tree-lined residential streets, a compact downtown of locally owned shops and cafés, and a steady calendar of campus events give the place a year-round energy, while the surrounding rolling farmland and woodlands of the northwestern corner of the state keep it firmly rooted in rural Pennsylvania. New Wilmington sits about 65 miles north of Pittsburgh and roughly 20 miles southeast of Youngstown, Ohio, placing it within easy reach of both metro areas while feeling a world apart from them.
Just a short drive south of New Wilmington, McConnell's Mill State Park draws outdoor enthusiasts with its dramatic Slippery Rock Gorge, the historic 1874 McConnell's Mill Covered Bridge, and a network of hiking trails that trace the gorge rim and the Slippery Rock Creek below. The park is about 20 minutes from the borough and offers some of the most photographed scenery in Lawrence County, particularly in autumn when the hardwood canopy turns vivid shades of red and gold.
A bit farther east, Moraine State Park spans more than 16,000 acres in neighboring Butler County and centers on Lake Arthur, a 3,200-acre impoundment that is popular for sailing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and swimming. The park is roughly 30 to 40 minutes from New Wilmington and adds a complementary water-based recreation option, with a paved lakeshore trail, picnic areas, and a well-regarded museum on the glacial geology of the region.
A few minutes down the road, the tiny village of Volant offers a contrasting kind of outing: a handful of country stores, quilt and craft shops, and a few small inns gathered along a single short stretch of road, giving visitors a glimpse of the rural Amish and Mennonite communities of the area. Closer still, the city of New Castle, the seat of Lawrence County, brings bigger-city conveniences, restaurants, and the Hoyt Center for the Arts within about a 15-minute drive.
For short-term rental owners, New Wilmington is a quietly appealing base. The borough pulls a reliable stream of college-related visitors on weekends for admissions events, athletic competitions, and graduation, while its proximity to McConnell's Mill, Moraine State Park, and the larger Pittsburgh and Youngstown metros gives outdoor travelers and visiting families a reason to extend their stays. The combination of small-town charm, an active institutional calendar, and easy access to some of western Pennsylvania's most scenic state parks makes New Wilmington a natural fit for guests who want a peaceful setting with a lot to do within an hour's drive.