Performance indicators for the Gap short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Gap.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
While STRs are technically legal under Pennsylvania state law, the regulations present significant challenges for investors due to zoning uncertainty in Gap specifically, complex multi-jurisdictional compliance requirements (state, county, local), high tax obligations (6% state + local hotel taxes), and the 'Slice of Life' Supreme Court decision allowing municipalities to ban STRs entirely if not explicitly permitted in zoning ordinances.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Gap, PA
Gap is a small unincorporated village in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, nestled in the rolling hills of Pennsylvania Dutch Country in the southeastern part of the state. With a population of only a few thousand residents, it retains a quiet, rural character defined by farmlands, country roads, and a slower pace of life. The village sits along the historic Lincoln Highway (US Route 30) and serves as a gateway to the Amish and Mennonite communities that have shaped Lancaster County's identity for centuries. It lies approximately 60 miles west of Philadelphia and about 15 miles east of the city of Lancaster, making it an accessible rural escape within easy reach of the Mid-Atlantic's major metropolitan areas.
Surrounding the village, the broader Pennsylvania Dutch Country offers one of the most distinctive cultural landscapes in the eastern United States. Visitors can explore scenic byways lined with horse-drawn buggies, family-operated farms, and roadside produce stands that showcase the region's agricultural heritage. The area around Gap is dotted with working farms, covered bridges, and country stores that have served travelers for generations, offering an authentic glimpse into a way of life that has endured for hundreds of years. Lancaster County itself is widely regarded as one of the most popular tourist destinations in Pennsylvania, drawing visitors interested in both its cultural traditions and its natural beauty.
A short drive east of Gap, the village of Intercourse and the surrounding area are home to Kitchen Kettle Village, a charming collection of shops, eateries, and craft demonstrations centered on Pennsylvania Dutch foodways and artisanship. About 20 minutes west of Gap, the town of Strasburg is a beloved destination for families and rail enthusiasts, anchored by the Strasburg Rail Road, America's oldest continuously operating railroad. The Strasburg area also includes the Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania and the National Toy Train Museum, making it a full day of attractions for visitors of all ages. A bit further west, the city of Lancaster offers a walkable downtown filled with historic architecture, the Central Market (one of the country's oldest farmers' markets), restaurants, and galleries.
For short-term rental investors, Gap offers a compelling combination of small-town authenticity and proximity to Lancaster County's most-visited attractions. Guests who stay in the area can enjoy peaceful rural surroundings while remaining within a short drive of cultural landmarks, family-friendly destinations, and the broader Brandywine and Chesapeake Bay region beyond. The village's location along a major east-west corridor makes it a convenient base for travelers exploring both Pennsylvania Dutch Country and the wider Mid-Atlantic, supporting steady year-round interest from road-trippers, families, and heritage tourists alike.