Performance indicators for the Eagles Mere short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Eagles Mere.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs are explicitly allowed in Eagles Mere, but investors must obtain a zoning permit, comply with noise/parking rules, and meet the Eagles Mere Association’s temporary membership, guest list, and beach access requirements. The process is known and manageable via Code Inspections and local property managers, though it adds multi-jurisdictional compliance and moderate operational duties.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Eagles Mere, PA
Eagles Mere is a tiny borough tucked into the Endless Mountains of Sullivan County, Pennsylvania, with a year-round population of only around 120 residents. The community has the feel of a turn-of-the-century Victorian summer resort, its quiet streets lined with century-old cottages, inns, and clapboard homes clustered around a single glacial lake. It is best known as a low-key, old-fashioned getaway for families and nature lovers drawn to its calm waters and wooded setting, and it serves as a gateway to some of the most scenic stretches of north-central Pennsylvania. The nearest major city is Scranton, about 55 miles to the northeast, while Philadelphia and New York City both sit roughly 160 to 180 miles southeast, generally a three-hour drive in good traffic.
At the heart of the town is Eagles Mere Lake, a 110-acre spring-fed glacial lake that has been the centerpiece of the community since the late 1800s. The lake is ringed by a public beach, walking paths, and a collection of historic boathouses, and it offers swimming, kayaking, canoeing, and catch-and-release fishing during the warmer months. Most of the borough's cottages and inns sit within a short walk of the shoreline, and the lake is essentially a five-minute stroll from anywhere in town.
Just a few miles south of Eagles Mere, Worlds End State Park draws visitors with its dramatic Loyalsock Canyon vistas, the Loyalsock River, and miles of marked hiking trails ranging from gentle valley walks to steep climbs up Mount Worden and Haystack Mountain. The park is roughly a 15-minute drive from the village and is a popular day trip for hiking, picnicking, and fall foliage viewing. The surrounding Loyalsock State Forest adds tens of thousands of acres of additional public land for backcountry exploration, cross-country skiing, and trout fishing along remote streams.
To the north, the small city of Williamsport, about 35 miles away, offers a fuller slate of restaurants, breweries, museums, and the riverside trails of Susquehanna State Park for day-tripping visitors who want a change of pace from the forested hills.
Eagles Mere makes a compelling base for short-term rentals precisely because of its small scale and well-preserved character. Visitors come for the lake, the hiking, and the unhurried pace, and the surrounding state parks and forests ensure there is plenty to do in every season. With limited lodging options in the borough itself and steady demand from Philadelphia, New York, and Harrisburg weekenders, well-located cabins and cottages near the lake have a natural appeal for guests seeking a quiet, nature-focused escape.