Performance indicators for the Madison short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Madison.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are technically allowed in Madison Village R‑2 but only on a handful of arterial streets (East/West Main, River) and require a conditional‑use permit with annual renewal ($200 + $50), insurance, safety equipment, and a <30‑day stay cap; in unincorporated Madison County, STRs are prohibited on single‑family parcels, leaving most of the market off‑limits and raising due‑diligence risk.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Madison, OH
Madison is a small village in Lake County, Ohio, perched along the southern shore of Lake Erie in the northeastern corner of the state. With a population of roughly 3,000 residents, it has the unhurried feel of a rural Great Lakes community, surrounded by vineyards, farmland, and stretches of lakefront. The village sits about 45 miles northeast of Cleveland, a drive of roughly 45 to 55 minutes via I-90, and it serves as a quiet gateway to the broader Grand River Valley and the resort communities that line Lake Erie's shoreline.
Just minutes from the village, Geneva State Park spreads across several hundred acres of Lake Erie frontage to the west. The park includes a marina, a sand beach, picnic areas, and a network of trails through meadows and woodlands, making it a popular spot for swimming, boating, fishing, and sunset-watching on the lake. From Madison, the drive to the park entrance is only about 10 minutes west along the lakeshore road.
To the west of Madison, the small resort community of Geneva-on-the-Lake anchors the area's tourist scene. Established in the late 1800s as one of Ohio's first lakeside resorts, it retains a nostalgic strip of attractions, arcades, restaurants, and a public beach that draw visitors throughout the summer months. Geneva-on-the-Lake is roughly a 10-minute drive from Madison, and the two communities share a similar visitor base of families, boaters, and weekenders from Cleveland and Pittsburgh.
The countryside surrounding Madison forms the heart of the Grand River Valley American Viticultural Area, one of Ohio's most acclaimed wine-growing regions. Dozens of family-owned vineyards and wineries lie within a short drive in every direction, many offering tasting rooms, restaurants, and live music on weekends. The Grand River itself winds through the surrounding landscape before emptying into Lake Erie, and the river corridor provides additional opportunities for paddling, fishing, and scenic drives through rolling countryside.
For a more rugged outdoor experience, Headlands Beach State Park in nearby Mentor features the largest natural sand beach in Ohio, along with walking trails and a nature center. It is approximately a 20-minute drive west of Madison and pairs well with a day spent exploring the broader lakeshore. To the east, Ashtabula County is also home to one of the largest concentrations of covered bridges in the country, a quiet draw for photography enthusiasts and history lovers passing through the region.
Madison's combination of lakefront access, a thriving wine scene, and easy proximity to both Cleveland and the small resort towns along Lake Erie gives it a versatile appeal. Travelers seeking a quieter, more pastoral base than a major city will find that the village offers access to beaches, vineyards, parks, and small-town charm in every direction, making it a natural fit for a short-term rental that doubles as a home base for exploring northeastern Ohio.