Performance indicators for the Elyria short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Elyria.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs are treated as lodging and allowed via administrative or conditional use review in Downtown, Corridor, and Commercial districts, with a clear but moderate permitting and review process; no explicit STR caps or city STR licensing are specified. However, operations in Residential districts lack permitted lodging status and typically require variances, creating location-driven compliance complexity but manageable investor risk.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Elyria, OH
Elyria is a city in Lorain County in northeastern Ohio, with an approximate population of around 53,000 residents. Situated along the Black River, it serves as the county seat of Lorain County and carries the character of a working-class industrial city with a revitalizing downtown and a strong sense of community heritage. Elyria is best known as a regional hub between Cleveland and the Lake Erie shore communities, offering visitors a quieter, more affordable base within easy reach of major metropolitan attractions, the lake, and several notable college towns. It lies roughly 30 miles west of Cleveland, a drive of about 35 to 45 minutes via the Ohio Turnpike or Interstate 80, placing it squarely within the Cleveland metropolitan orbit while maintaining its own distinct identity.
One of the city's signature green spaces is Cascade Park, a roughly 150-acre historic park in the heart of Elyria. Constructed in part through Depression-era public works programs, the park is anchored by a 50-foot limestone cascade and waterfall, walking trails, picnic areas, and a vintage carousel that has been operating for generations. It functions as a year-round gathering place for families, with seasonal events and riverfront paths along the Black River. The park sits just minutes from most points in the city.
About 15 miles to the west lies the small college town of Oberlin, home to the historically significant Oberlin College, the first institution in the United States to admit women and one of the earliest to admit African American students. Visitors come for the Allen Memorial Art Museum, the Conservatory of Music performances, and the walkable downtown lined with cafés and bookshops. The drive from Elyria takes roughly 20 to 25 minutes.
To the north, the city of Lorain and its Lake Erie waterfront are within about a 15-minute drive. Here, visitors find beaches, fishing piers, a lighthouse, and charter boat access onto the lake. The lakefront becomes a particular draw in summer, when sunsets and beach days complement Elyria's quieter pace.
Further afield, the world-famous Cedar Point amusement park in Sandusky is roughly an hour's drive west, making Elyria a practical alternative to staying in pricier resort towns for thrill-seekers. Closer to home, Cleveland's cultural institutions, including its Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and major league sports venues, are easily reached for a day trip.
Elyria's appeal as a short-term rental base comes from this rare balance: affordable, spacious accommodations in a real Ohio community, paired with quick access to Lake Erie, the Oberlin cultural scene, Cedar Point, and the broader Cleveland region. Its central location along the main interstate corridor makes it a convenient crossroads for travelers exploring northeast Ohio.