Performance indicators for the Caldwell short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Caldwell.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Allowable but require county-level registration, transient guest tax compliance, and zoning adherence with limited local specificity for Caldwell, Ohio; moderate permitting/compliance process without clear caps.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Caldwell, OH
Caldwell is a small village in Noble County, in the rolling, forested landscape of southeastern Ohio. With a population of roughly 1,700 residents, it serves as the county seat and has the quiet, unpretentious character of a rural Appalachian community, where historic brick storefronts line a compact downtown and the surrounding countryside is shaped by farms, woodlands, and small lakes. Caldwell is best understood as a gateway to the outdoor recreation, wildlife attractions, and scenic byways of the Noble County region, drawing visitors who prefer a slower pace over the busier tourist corridors further east or west. The nearest major city is Columbus, located approximately 90 miles to the northwest, while the slightly closer city of Cambridge lies to the northeast.
One of the most prominent nearby destinations is The Wilds, a large conservation and safari park situated on reclaimed strip-mine land in Muskingum County. Roughly a 30-minute drive east of Caldwell near the village of Cumberland, it offers guided open-air safari tours where visitors can see rhinos, giraffes, and bison roaming expansive pastures, along with lodging at the on-site lodge and seasonal special events. It is one of the most distinctive wildlife experiences in the Midwest and draws visitors from across Ohio and beyond.
A shorter trip northwest of town leads to Seneca Lake, the largest body of water in Ohio's Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District, with portions of the lake and the surrounding Seneca Lake State Park falling within Noble County. About 20 minutes from Caldwell, the area is popular for fishing, boating, swimming at the beach, and camping, and it tends to be a focal point for warm-weather visitors to the region. The rolling hills surrounding the reservoir make it a particularly scenic stop during the autumn foliage season.
Closer to home, the Noble County Historical Society maintains a museum in downtown Caldwell that documents the county's settlement, agricultural heritage, and early industries, including its ties to the oil boom of the late 19th century. Within a similar radius, visitors will also find Wolf Run State Park, a quieter park with a small fishing lake, hiking trails, and family-friendly campsites that exemplifies the unhurried outdoor character of the area.
For short-term-rental owners and investors, Caldwell offers a compelling case as a base for travelers who want access to The Wilds, Seneca Lake, and the broader southeastern Ohio outdoors without the higher costs and seasonal congestion of more famous destinations. Its rural setting, central location within Noble County, and proximity to a genuinely unusual set of regional attractions make it well suited to guests seeking an affordable, nature-focused Ohio getaway.