Performance indicators for the Valley Stream short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Valley Stream.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Valley Stream lacks a clear local STR ordinance, forcing investors to navigate NY State MDL and Nassau County rules (hosted-only in Class A multiple dwellings, unhosted allowed in 1–2 family homes), plus a two‑year rental permit with inspections or architect certification and penalties up to $3,000 and possible jail time. Combined sales tax (~8.6%) plus 3% county hotel tax add cost/complexity, while county inspections and renewal obligations increase compliance burden, raising investor risk.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Valley Stream, NY
Valley Stream is a village located in the Town of Hempstead in Nassau County, New York, situated on the western end of Long Island. With a population of approximately 37,000 residents, it functions as a comfortable commuter community with a quiet, suburban character that contrasts with the bustle of the New York City metro area just to the west. The village is best known as a gateway to Long Island's South Shore beaches and as a convenient base for travelers using JFK International Airport, which sits a few miles to the west. Manhattan is roughly 20 miles west, easily reachable by car or by Long Island Rail Road, which maintains a stop right in the village center.
Just minutes from the village center, Valley Stream State Park offers a welcome patch of greenery in this otherwise developed corner of Long Island. The park features athletic fields, picnic areas, walking paths, and a swimming pool during the warmer months, making it a favorite for local families, joggers, and casual visitors. It is roughly a five-minute drive from most points in the village and provides an easy opportunity for guests who want outdoor time without leaving town.
A short drive south brings visitors to the Atlantic Ocean beaches that draw day-trippers and weekenders throughout the summer. Long Beach, the barrier-island city about eight miles south of Valley Stream, boasts a famous two-and-a-half-mile boardwalk, wide sandy beaches, and a lively downtown with restaurants and surf shops. It is one of the South Shore's most popular warm-weather destinations and a natural fit for guests staying in the village.
A bit farther east, Jones Beach State Park is a marquee Long Island attraction and a beloved summer destination for residents of the New York City region. Known for its expansive white-sand ocean beach, the Jones Beach Boardwalk, summer concerts at the outdoor amphitheater, and a vintage art-deco feel, the park sits roughly 20 miles east of Valley Stream and is typically reached in around 30 minutes by car. Guests who base themselves in the village can pair a morning in the city or a flight at the airport with an afternoon swim in the surf.
Valley Stream's appeal for short-term rental operators lies in its rare combination of suburban calm and urban accessibility. The village offers the feel of a residential neighborhood with tree-lined streets, a walkable downtown corridor, and easy parking, while its position near JFK, the LIRR, and the Belt Parkway places virtually all of Long Island and New York City within easy reach. Whether guests are visiting for a beach vacation, business tied to the airport, or a dual city-and-shore itinerary, the village's central position on western Long Island makes it a versatile and convenient home base throughout the year.