Performance indicators for the Southold short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Southold.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Allowed but constrained by the 14‑night minimum, mandatory inspections, $300 biennial permit and evolving framework; non‑primary rentals face a 1% cap and lottery, with heavy fines and proactive enforcement creating compliance and investment risk.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Southold, NY
Southold is a town on the North Fork of Long Island in Suffolk County, New York, with a population of roughly 22,000 spread across several small hamlets and villages. Founded in 1640, it is one of the oldest English settlements in the country and has a quiet, maritime character defined by working farms, vineyards, fishing fleets, and clapboard houses. The town is best known as the heart of Long Island's wine country and as a gateway to Shelter Island, reached by a short ferry from the nearby village of Greenport. Southold sits at the eastern end of Long Island, about 90 miles east of New York City.
A short drive east of the hamlet of Southold brings visitors to Greenport, a walkable harbor village lined with boutiques, restaurants, and the historic 1894 carousel in Mitchell Park. The village is also the departure point for ferries across to Shelter Island, making it a natural side trip from a stay in Southold.
At the very tip of the North Fork, Orient Beach State Park offers an extensive stretch of shoreline on a narrow spit of land, with swimming, picnic areas, and a small marina. The drive from Southold hamlet to the park is roughly 15 minutes along Route 25, and the same route passes the Horton Point Lighthouse, a nineteenth-century beacon on the bluff above Long Island Sound.
Just across Peconic Bay, Shelter Island provides a slower-paced counterpoint to the North Fork's vineyard-lined roads. Mashomack Preserve, which protects nearly 2,800 acres of salt marsh, beaches, and oak forest, is one of the largest nature preserves on Long Island and is reached by a brief ferry ride from Greenport. Inland, the surrounding countryside is dotted with family farms and vineyards that have made the region a destination for farm-to-table dining and tasting rooms.
For short-term rental owners, Southold combines the draw of Long Island wine country with the novelty of a ferry-connected island getaway, all within easy reach of New York City. The town's blend of historic character, agricultural landscape, and waterfront access makes it a versatile base for travelers seeking either a quiet weekend escape or an active exploration of the East End.