Performance indicators for the Honeoye short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Honeoye.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are currently allowed but no specific rules are finalized; town is developing likely registration, inspections, occupancy caps and fees, creating uncertainty and compliance risk.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Honeoye, NY
Honeoye is a small hamlet in the Town of Richmond, in Ontario County, New York, sitting at the northern tip of Honeoye Lake in the heart of the Finger Lakes region. With a modest year-round population of roughly 700 residents, the community has a quiet, rural, lake-town character that draws visitors looking for outdoor recreation rather than urban amenities. It is best known as a relaxed base for enjoying one of the smaller Finger Lakes, and serves as a convenient gateway to the broader Finger Lakes wine country, gorges, and state parks. The nearest major city is Rochester, New York, located approximately 30 miles to the north, with a typical drive of about 45 minutes.
Honeoye Lake itself is the centerpiece of the area, a roughly four-and-a-half-mile-long Finger Lake popular for warm-water fishing, small-craft boating, kayaking, and swimming. A public boat launch and lakeside park put visitors on the water within minutes of the hamlet, and the lake's calm, family-friendly coves make it a frequent alternative to the busier larger Finger Lakes. (Honeoye Lake)
About 25 miles southwest of Honeoye, Letchworth State Park — often called the "Grand Canyon of the East" — offers more than 14,000 acres of deep gorges, three major waterfalls, and the Genesee River. The drive typically takes around 40 minutes and rewards visitors with hiking trails, hot-air balloon launches, whitewater rafting in season, and some of the most dramatic fall foliage in the Northeast.
Roughly 15 miles northeast of Honeoye, the city of Canandaigua — the Ontario County seat — features a walkable historic Main Street, a public lakefront, and Sonnenberg Gardens and Mansion State Historic Park, a 50-acre Victorian estate known for its formal gardens and summer tours. It functions naturally as a day-trip destination for guests staying in Honeoye.
Honeoye's appeal for short-term rentals comes from the combination of a small, affordable hamlet setting with direct lake access, an easy commute to Rochester, and a wide ring of regional draws including the Finger Lakes wineries, the gorges of Letchworth, and the historic small towns of Ontario County — all of which give owners a steady mix of summer lake traffic, fall-foliage visitors, and shoulder-season weekenders.