Performance indicators for the Greenport short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Greenport.
Loading top listings...
Unfriendly to Investors
Short-term rentals are explicitly prohibited in Greenport, NY as of Jan 1, 2025, and violations incur escalating fines and permit revocation. Although the Village Board is considering a highly constrained STR permit program, its terms are not yet adopted, creating high legal and financial risk for investors.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Greenport, NY
Greenport is a small maritime village in Suffolk County, on the North Fork of Long Island in New York State. With a year-round population of roughly 2,200, it has the feel of a New England fishing town transplanted to the East End, complete with a working harbor, clapboard storefronts, and a longstanding seafaring identity. It serves as the northern gateway to Shelter Island and as a popular base for exploring the North Fork's vineyards, farm stands, and lighthouse-studded coastline. New York City lies about 90 miles to the southwest, roughly a 2.5- to 3-hour drive depending on traffic, or closer to two hours by the Hampton Jitney bus or the Long Island Rail Road.
The Shelter Island Ferry departs from the heart of the Greenport harbor, and the crossing to Shelter Island takes only a few minutes by car ferry or passenger boat. Shelter Island is a low-key summer haven of bayside beaches, cycling routes, and quiet inns, making it a natural day trip for travelers who want to swap Greenport's bustle for an even slower pace.
Downtown Greenport itself is compact and walkable, with a stretch of Front Street and Main Street lined with independent shops, seafood restaurants, and ice cream parlors. Mitchell Park, set on the harborfront, is home to a beloved historic carousel and functions as the village's social hub during the warmer months, hosting summer concerts, a farmers' market, and outdoor events with views across the harbor.
The surrounding North Fork is one of New York's most distinctive wine regions, with dozens of vineyards and tasting rooms within a short drive of the village center. The area's maritime climate and sandy soils support both vinifera grapes and a thriving farm-stand tradition, and many visitors tour the North Fork by car or bicycle over a long weekend, pairing winery stops with u-pick farms and seafood shacks.
A bit further east, Orient Point marks the tail of the North Fork and is the departure point for the Cross Sound Ferry to New London, Connecticut. The nearby Horton Point Lighthouse, a nineteenth-century landmark perched on the bluffs above Long Island Sound, offers a glimpse into the area's navigational history along with sweeping water views.
Greenport is a compelling base for short-term rentals because it pairs a walkable, character-filled village core with easy access to a string of complementary destinations — Shelter Island, the wineries, Orient Point, and the broader South Fork beyond. It draws a mix of weekenders, summer families, ferry-bound travelers, and shoulder-season visitors who come for the food, boats, and slow coastal rhythm, giving the area a steady cadence of demand that extends beyond a single peak season.