Performance indicators for the Great Valley short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Great Valley.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs are explicitly permitted citywide with moderate licensing ($125–$400/yr), defined operational rules (120-day cap in RR/HRC zones; AG zone more lenient), and clear compliance/reporting requirements; the cap and active enforcement create meaningful constraints but remain manageable for most investors.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Great Valley, NY
Great Valley is a small rural town in Cattaraugus County in western New York, home to approximately 2,000 residents. Nestled in the foothills of the Allegheny Mountains in the Southern Tier region, the community has a quiet, wooded character with a landscape of forests, streams, and gentle terrain. It serves as a peaceful gateway to several of western New York's most popular recreational destinations, most notably the resort village of Ellicottville and the sprawling Allegany State Park. The town is located roughly 60 miles south of Buffalo, with the Pennsylvania border not far to the south.
Just a short drive north of Great Valley lies the village of Ellicottville, one of the region's popular four-season destinations. The village is best known as the home of Holiday Valley, one of the largest ski resorts in New York State, which draws crowds in winter for skiing, snowboarding, and tubing. When the snow melts, the resort shifts to a summer playground with lift-served mountain biking, a golf course, and a resort pool, while the walkable downtown invites visitors to browse boutiques, sample local restaurants, and enjoy the small-town atmosphere.
A short drive south and west of Great Valley brings visitors to Allegany State Park, one of the largest state parks in New York. Encompassing roughly 65,000 acres of forest, the park offers an extensive trail system for hiking and cross-country skiing, lakes for fishing and paddling, and numerous campgrounds. It is also recognized for dark sky viewing, making it a destination for stargazing. Wildlife viewing and fall foliage are additional draws, and the park hosts events and ranger programs throughout the year.
Nearby, the city of Salamanca is home to a Seneca gaming and entertainment complex on the Allegany Indian Reservation. The resort includes a hotel, multiple restaurants, live entertainment venues, and gaming floors, offering an evening complement to the area's outdoor recreation and drawing visitors throughout the year.
Great Valley is a compelling base for short-term rentals because it places guests within easy reach of four-season recreation while preserving the tranquility of a rural setting. Visitors can spend the day skiing, mountain biking, hiking, or exploring nearby villages, then return to a quieter, more spacious environment. With Ellicottville's peak winter and summer demand, the steady appeal of Allegany State Park, and the year-round draw of the casino, the area supports a varied visitor base and a strong case for owners looking to invest in western New York's outdoor tourism market.