Performance indicators for the Grahamsville short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Grahamsville.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are technically allowed and licensing is well‑defined, but non‑resident licenses are capped and not being issued, forcing investors to buy into an existing license to operate. Owner‑occupied pathways require full‑time local presence, inspections, insurance, neighbor notifications, emergency response commitments, and Ulster County occupancy tax filings, raising compliance cost and complexity. These caps and obligations create material investor risk despite clarity of the regulatory framework.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Grahamsville, NY
Grahamsville is a small hamlet in the Town of Neversink in Sullivan County, New York, nestled in the wooded folds of the Catskill Mountains. With a population of only a few hundred residents, it carries the unhurried, forest-edge character of a traditional Catskills community and serves as a quiet base for visitors drawn to the region's reservoirs, trails, and ridgelines. The hamlet lies roughly ninety miles northwest of New York City, an approximately two- to two-and-a-half-hour drive depending on traffic, and is roughly two hours south of Albany, giving it easy reach from both major metropolitan areas.
About ten miles north of the hamlet, in the community of Claryville, Frost Valley YMCA occupies a vast tract of forest along the Rondout Creek valley and is one of the largest year-round camp and conference centers in the country. The property offers a wide range of outdoor programming, including guided hikes, horseback riding, and a network of trails open to day visitors during much of the year, making it a familiar anchor for families and groups exploring the western Catskills.
To the west and south of Grahamsville, the Sundown Wild Forest covers tens of thousands of acres of rugged Catskill terrain and contains some of the region's most popular backcountry hiking. The forest is home to the high peaks of Peekamoose and Table Mountain, as well as long stretches of the Willowemoc and Neversink creek corridors, and offers everything from short waterfall walks to multi-day backpacking routes.
Just south and east of the hamlet lie the Rondout and Neversink Reservoirs, two of the many Catskills impoundments that supply New York City with drinking water. While recreational access along the water is limited, the surrounding roads offer scenic drives through the heavily forested Neversink valley, and the reservoirs remain a defining visual feature of the area, particularly in autumn when the surrounding hills turn color.
For short-term rental owners, Grahamsville's appeal lies in the combination of small-town quiet, four-season Catskill scenery, and proximity to the New York metro area. Visitors come for the hiking, the foliage, the long-running Little World's Fair, and the simple retreat from city life, and the hamlet's position at the meeting point of several wild forests, reservoirs, and traditional Catskill communities makes it an unusually well-placed base for exploring the region.