Performance indicators for the Gardiner short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Gardiner.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Gardiner permits STRs citywide but constrains them with a strict 100‑license cap and a priority system favoring existing county‑registered operators, limiting new market entry. Compliance burdens include mandatory municipal licensing, safety/inspection, insurance, emergency contact protocols, plus Ulster County hotel tax filings. Evolving regs and unpredictable cap availability heighten investment risk and make expansion planning difficult.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Gardiner, NY
Gardiner is a small rural town in Ulster County, New York, set in the rolling countryside of the Hudson Valley just south of the Shawangunk Ridge. With a population of roughly 5,500, it carries a quiet, agricultural character, anchored by working farms, apple orchards, and a low-key main hamlet that feels a world away from urban life. The town is widely known as a gateway to the Shawangunk Ridge, often called "the Gunks," and it lies approximately 90 miles north of New York City, about a two-hour drive via the New York State Thruway, with Kingston a short fifteen-minute drive to the north.
Just minutes from the center of Gardiner, Minnewaska State Park Preserve spreads across thousands of acres of rugged cliffs, hardwood forest, and sky lakes. The preserve features well-marked trail networks that lead to overlooks such as Awosting Falls and to its various sky lakes, and it is a favorite for hiking, mountain biking, swimming, and cross-country skiing in the colder months. Right alongside it, the cliffs and forests of the Shawangunk Ridge draw world-class rock climbers to Gardiner's doorstep throughout the year.
For climbers, hikers, and casual visitors alike, Mohonk Preserve — only a few miles from town — is one of the most celebrated traditional climbing areas on the East Coast, with roughly a thousand rock routes and an extensive carriage-road and trail system used by hikers, runners, and horseback riders in every season. The preserve's iconic cliffs and the historic Mohonk Mountain House perched above the valley are regional landmarks in their own right.
A short drive north brings visitors to the village of New Paltz, home to the Huguenot Street Historic District, a National Historic Landmark featuring a row of original 17th- and 18th-century stone houses built by French Huguenot settlers. The surrounding area also hosts numerous farm stands, u-pick orchards, and tasting rooms, and Gardiner sits within the broader Shawangunk Wine Trail region, with several family-run vineyards scattered among the orchards and ridgelines.
With its mix of outdoor adventure, agricultural character, and proximity to both New York City and the smaller cultural hubs of the Hudson Valley, Gardiner offers short-term rental guests year-round appeal — from fall foliage and harvest season to summer climbing and swimming, with the Catskills, Kingston, and the river towns of the Hudson all within easy reach for day trips.