Performance indicators for the Clayton short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Clayton.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Clayton STRs appear legally allowed at the state level, but the city has no identified ordinances in the provided content. The resulting uncertainty around local permitting, zoning, caps, and enforcement creates a costly and unclear compliance path for investors.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Clayton, NM
Clayton is a small town in Union County, in the far northeastern corner of New Mexico, with an approximate population of around 2,500 residents. It sits in the high plains near the point where New Mexico meets Texas, Oklahoma, and Colorado, giving the town a tri-state crossroads character and a relaxed, ranching-community feel. Clayton is best known as a gateway to some of northeastern New Mexico's most distinctive landscapes, and as a stopover on the historic Ozark Trail and old Route 66 corridor. The nearest major city is Amarillo, Texas, roughly 110 miles to the southeast.
Just outside town, Capulin Volcano National Monument draws visitors with a strikingly symmetrical cinder cone rising from the surrounding plains. A winding road climbs to the rim, where short trails circle the crater and offer panoramic views of the surrounding grasslands, the distant Sangre de Cristo Mountains, and on the clearest days, parts of four states. The monument sits about a 30-minute drive northeast of Clayton and anchors much of the area's tourism traffic.
About 12 miles north of town, Clayton Lake State Park combines outdoor recreation with one of the region's most unusual paleontological sites. The park's spillway has revealed hundreds of dinosaur footprints from the late Cretaceous period, preserved in a layer of rock that visitors can walk right up to, while the lake itself supports fishing, small-boat paddling, and quiet campgrounds surrounded by juniper and cottonwood.
Clayton's compact downtown reflects its early-20th-century heritage as a railroad and highway town, with a handful of preserved brick storefronts and locally owned diners giving the main street its unhurried pace. The area also sits within reach of broader prairie and canyon landscapes on the surrounding rangelands, where visitors come for hunting, wildlife viewing, and the sense of wide-open sky that defines this corner of New Mexico.
For short-term rental owners, Clayton offers an appealing mix of low competition, a steady flow of travelers moving through the tri-state region, and a small cluster of genuinely distinctive natural and historical attractions within an easy drive. Road-trippers tracing old Route 66, families visiting Capulin Volcano, and anglers and hunters working the surrounding plains all contribute to consistent seasonal demand, making the town a useful base for exploring a quieter, less-trafficked side of New Mexico.