Performance indicators for the Newton short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Newton.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Allowed under general codes but regulatory uncertainty and patchy compliance burden (zoning checks, fire safety, state tax) create notable risk; potential for future caps/fees adds investor caution.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Newton, NJ
Newton is the county seat of Sussex County, in the rolling, wooded northwest corner of New Jersey known as the Skylands region. With a population of roughly 8,000 residents, the town has the feel of a small, walkable country community anchored by a traditional Main Street courthouse square. It is best known as a gateway to the Kittatinny Mountains, the Delaware Water Gap, and the broader northwest New Jersey and Pocono Mountains outdoor-recreation region. New York City lies about 60 miles to the southeast, generally a 90-minute drive depending on traffic, while the Pennsylvania border is only a short drive west.
Just minutes from the town center, Kittatinny Valley State Park spreads across more than 5,000 acres of fields, forests, and the long, narrow shores of Lake Aeroflex and Gardner's Pond. Visitors come for hiking and biking along the Paulinskill Valley Trail, fishing, picnicking, and in winter, cross-country skiing and ice fishing, making it a year-round draw for guests who want to experience the countryside without straying far from their rental.
About a fifteen-minute drive north of Newton, Sterling Hill Mining Museum in Ogdensburg draws visitors into one of the oldest and most productive zinc mines in the United States. The site is famous for its underground mine tour and for the adjoining Thomas S. Warren Museum of Fluorescence, which houses one of the world's largest collections of fluorescent minerals. It is the kind of offbeat, family-friendly attraction that gives a rural stay an extra dimension.
Roughly thirty minutes west of town, the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area follows the Delaware River along the New Jersey–Pennsylvania border. The recreation area offers more than 100 miles of hiking trails, river access for kayaking and tubing, scenic drives, and views from Mount Tammany. Closer to home, High Point State Park, about twenty-five minutes north, contains the highest elevation in New Jersey and its distinctive obelisk monument, plus additional trails and a lake for swimming and boating.
Downtown Newton itself, organized around the historic Sussex County Courthouse, is a compact cluster of small shops, restaurants, antique stores, and community events that give the town a recognizable sense of place.
Taken together, Newton offers short-term-rental owners a rare combination: a small, charming town with its own identity, immediate access to state parks and rural scenery, proximity to the Delaware Water Gap and the Poconos for outdoor tourism, and a reasonable drive to the New York metropolitan market. That mix of countryside appeal, four-season recreation, and regional connectivity makes it an attractive base for guests seeking a quieter alternative to the more heavily trafficked corners of New Jersey.