Performance indicators for the Hightstown short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Hightstown.
Loading top listings...
Very Investor friendly
Hightstown has no STR‑specific ordinances, permits, caps, or registration fees, allowing STRs where zoning, building, fire, and tax rules are met; the state transient occupancy tax and safety codes apply but do not impose city‑level burdens. The lack of municipal restrictions and supportive tone for underlying residential use keeps investor compliance straightforward and cost‑controlled.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Hightstown, NJ
Hightstown is a small borough in Mercer County, in central New Jersey, with a population of roughly 5,500 residents. It carries the feel of a quiet, walkable small town, with a tree-lined historic core, late-Victorian and early-twentieth-century homes, and a long-standing identity tied to the Delaware Valley rail and farming traditions. Often considered a gateway to central New Jersey, Hightstown sits within easy reach of several larger hubs: Trenton, the state capital, lies about 12 miles to the west, and New York City is roughly 50 miles to the northeast, putting the borough in commuting distance of both the Princeton academic corridor and the broader New York metropolitan area.
Just a short drive southwest, the town of Princeton offers one of the region's most recognizable draws. Roughly 10 miles from Hightstown, Princeton is anchored by Princeton University and its surrounding historic district, including the centuries-old Nassau Hall, the Princeton University Art Museum, and a leafy downtown of independent bookshops, cafés, and restaurants that draws visitors year-round. The campus's Gothic architecture and the wooded Institute Woods and Marquand Park make the area a rewarding stop for travelers interested in both culture and outdoor strolling.
A few miles further southwest, in Hamilton Township, lies Grounds for Sculpture, a 42-acre park and sculpture garden set within a landscape of water features, woodland paths, and rotating contemporary installations. Roughly 20 minutes from Hightstown, it has become one of central New Jersey's signature cultural attractions, offering both indoor galleries and expansive outdoor grounds that change with the seasons.
For travelers seeking bigger-ticket entertainment, Six Flags Great Adventure in Jackson Township is about 25 miles to the southeast, with its roller coasters, safari off-road adventure, and water park making it a popular day trip for families. In the other direction, the Atlantic coast and the Jersey Shore beach towns begin roughly 35 to 40 miles to the east, putting boardwalk destinations, lighthouses, and oceanfront boardwalks within a manageable drive for a day excursion.
Hightstown's appeal for short-term rentals lies in this balance. It offers the calm of a small, established New Jersey borough while sitting at the intersection of multiple regional attractions: the academic and cultural offerings of Princeton, the sculpture gardens of Hamilton, the thrills of Six Flags, and the beaches of the Jersey Shore. Combined with its proximity to both Trenton and the New York–Philadelphia corridor, the borough provides a comfortable, central base from which visitors can experience a wide cross-section of central New Jersey without the noise or price tag of staying in the larger cities themselves.