Performance indicators for the Hackettstown short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Hackettstown.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
Hackettstown treats short‑term rentals under its general landlord registration and zoning/safety permitting regime, which imposes moderate costs and inspection requirements but does not impose explicit caps or outright bans. The biggest drivers of the B grade are the moderate licensing and fire‑safety inspection requirements and the lack of clear STR‑specific caps, making compliance a known but not overly burdensome process.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Hackettstown, NJ
Hackettstown is a small town of roughly 9,500 residents in Warren County, in the rolling hills of northwestern New Jersey. It carries a classic small-town character, with a walkable historic downtown anchored by 19th-century architecture and a long-standing connection to the surrounding Kittatinny Mountains and Musconetcong River valley. Best known as a base for outdoor recreation and as the home of Centenary University, Hackettstown sits about 55 miles west of New York City, making it a practical country escape for weekend visitors from the metropolitan region.
Just outside the town center, Stephens State Park offers a quick introduction to the area's natural side. The park follows a wooded stretch of the Musconetcong River and includes a campground, fishing access, and a section of the former Morris Canal towpath that has been converted into a hiking trail. It is only a short drive from anywhere in town and is a frequent starting point for visitors exploring the broader New Jersey Highlands.
A few miles south of Hackettstown, in the neighboring community of Allamuchy, stands Rutherfurd Hall, a country estate completed in 1907 for the philanthropist Albert Rutherfurd. The Tudor-style mansion is now a preserved historic site open for tours, weddings, and community events, providing a window into the area's Gilded Age past amid manicured grounds and surrounding forest.
Further afield, the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area lies roughly 25 to 30 miles to the northwest, straddling the New Jersey–Pennsylvania border along the Delaware River. The recreation area draws hikers, paddlers, and sightseers with its dramatic mountain ridges, well-known Appalachian Trail crossings, and river access points that remain popular throughout the warmer months and into fall foliage season.
For short-term rental owners, Hackettstown offers a quiet but well-positioned base that combines small-town character with ready access to a steady stream of regional attractions. Its proximity to New York City and the surrounding northern New Jersey suburbs gives it a built-in weekend traveler market, while nearby state parks, historic estates, and the Delaware Water Gap ensure guests have a variety of day-trip options in every season.