Performance indicators for the Budd Lake short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Budd Lake.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Status of STRs is unclear without ordinance text (potential ban or strict conditional-use rules), and NJ/Mount Olive can involve permitting, inspections, fees, and caps; uncertainty and administrative burden raise investor risk.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Budd Lake, NJ
Budd Lake is a small, suburban census-designated place in Mount Olive Township, Morris County, in the northwestern corner of New Jersey. The community has a population of roughly 8,000 to 9,000 residents and takes its name from the body of water at its center, which is the largest natural lake in the state. The area has a quiet, residential character with a mix of older homes, newer developments, and wooded stretches, and it serves as a convenient gateway to the wider Skylands region of northwest New Jersey. Budd Lake sits roughly 50 miles west of New York City, accessible by I-80, and is also within easy reach of northern New Jersey and the Pennsylvania border.
The lake itself, Budd Lake, is the centerpiece of the community and the primary local draw. It is a glacially formed lake popular with anglers for bass, pickerel, and catfish, and the surrounding area offers public access points and a few small beaches. A path known as the Lake Loop trail circles much of the shoreline, giving visitors an easy way to walk, jog, or birdwatch around the water without leaving the neighborhood.
Just a few minutes south of town, Allamuchy Mountain State Park sprawls across more than 8,000 acres of forested ridges, streams, and wetlands straddling the border of Warren and Sussex counties. The park includes sections of the Musconetcong River, miles of marked hiking and mountain biking trails, and connections to a network of state and county parklands. It is a popular year-round destination for outdoor enthusiasts, especially in fall when the foliage peaks.
A short drive west leads to Hackettstown, a small, walkable town that serves as the commercial hub for the surrounding rural townships. It is home to Centenary University, a historic main street with locally owned restaurants and shops, and a handful of community events. A few minutes beyond Hackettstown, Stephens State Park follows the Musconetcong River and includes a campground that draws visitors from across the region.
To the east, the larger Lake Hopatcong sits about fifteen minutes away and functions as a regional recreation hub, with boating, marinas, restaurants along its shoreline, and a longstanding identity as a New Jersey summer resort. Further afield, the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area, the Pocono Mountains, and a long list of Skylands-region farms, antique towns, and wineries are all within roughly an hour's drive.
For short-term rental owners, Budd Lake offers a compelling combination of suburban calm, a recognizable landmark in the lake, and quick access to outdoor recreation, small historic towns, and the broader New York metropolitan area. That mix of accessibility and small-town character makes it well suited to travelers seeking a quieter base within reach of the region's biggest draws.