Performance indicators for the Stonington short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Stonington.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are allowed but tightly controlled: non‑owner‑occupied units face a 1,000‑ft separation requirement, an annual cap, Planning Board conditional‑use review, inspections, and escalating fees (up to $500 per additional unit), creating compliance burdens and limiting inventory.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Stonington, ME
Stonington is a small coastal town situated on the southern end of Deer Isle in Hancock County, Maine, with a year-round population of roughly 1,000 residents. The community has long drawn its identity and livelihood from the working waters of Penobscot Bay, where lobster boats still depart at dawn and the harbor remains an active hub of the Maine lobster industry. Beyond its fishing heritage, Stonington is known for its quietly vibrant art scene, with galleries, studios, and the influence of the nearby Haystack Mountain School of Crafts lending it a creative, bohemian streak. It also serves as a gateway to some of the most unspoiled stretches of the Maine coast, including outlying islands and the dramatic landscapes of Acadia to the northeast. The town lies approximately 80 miles southeast of Bangor and roughly 130 miles northeast of Portland, with a drive time of about two hours to Acadia National Park.
One of the most compelling attractions within easy reach is Acadia National Park, located about 65 miles to the northeast along the coast. The park offers granite peaks, carriage roads, tide pools, and the scenic Park Loop Road, making it a destination that draws visitors from around the world. Many guests staying in Stonington use the town as a quieter, more affordable base for day trips to Acadia, returning each evening to the slower pace of island life.
Even closer is Isle au Haut, a rugged island reached by a seasonal mail-boat ferry that departs from the Stonington waterfront. Partly administered as part of Acadia National Park, the island offers miles of hiking trails, rocky shorelines, and a lighthouse, attracting day-trippers looking for a genuinely remote coastal experience without the crowds of the main park.
On the mainland side of the causeway, the village of Deer Isle and the surrounding peninsula offer additional draws, including the Haystack Mountain School of Crafts in nearby Liberty and a string of small galleries and studios that reflect the area's strong artistic community. The Eggemoggin Reach, the wide tidal strait separating Deer Isle from the mainland, is also a renowned sailing destination and a beautiful sight from shore.
For short-term rental investors, Stonington presents an appealing combination of authenticity, accessibility, and proximity to marquee destinations. Visitors who want a taste of Down East Maine without the bustle and pricing of Bar Harbor often find Stonington a more relaxed alternative, with its own harbor, food culture, and island-hopping opportunities. The result is a destination that supports year-round interest, peaking in summer and early fall, and rewards guests looking for a quieter, more artisanal side of the Maine coast.