Performance indicators for the Carlisle short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Carlisle.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
Short‑term rentals appear permitted with no city‑specific bans or caps; state taxes (6% sales tax + 1% TRT) and safety codes apply but are straightforward. The absence of documented local ordinances introduces permitting uncertainty and enforcement variability, making due diligence necessary but not prohibitive.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Carlisle, KY
Carlisle is a small, quiet city that serves as the county seat of Nicholas County, Kentucky, with a population of roughly 4,000 residents. Set in the rolling agricultural landscape of the northern Bluegrass region, the town has the unhurried feel of a traditional rural Kentucky community, with a compact historic downtown, tree-lined residential streets, and surrounding farmland that includes horse and cattle operations typical of the area. Carlisle is best known as the home of the annual Nicholas County Tobacco Festival and as the gateway to one of the state's most significant early historical sites, the Blue Licks Battlefield just to the south. It sits approximately 40 miles northeast of Lexington and roughly 60 miles southeast of Cincinnati, putting it within comfortable day-trip range of two much larger metropolitan areas.
A short drive south of town, Blue Licks Battlefield State Resort Park preserves the site of the 1782 Battle of Blue Licks, widely considered one of the final engagements of the American Revolutionary War. About eight to ten miles from downtown Carlisle, the park combines a small museum, a pioneer cemetery, walking trails, picnic areas, and a spring-fed lake, and it has long been a popular stop for travelers interested in frontier and Native American history. The interpretive center and the obelisk monument on the bluff overlooking the Licking River make it a natural anchor for visitors staying in the area.
To the northeast, about a thirty-minute drive, the river town of Maysville offers a walkable historic district overlooking the Ohio River, with nineteenth-century architecture, antique shops, and locally owned restaurants. Its location on the river historically made it an important landing and port, and the surviving commercial buildings along Front Street give the downtown a distinctive character that contrasts with the quieter countryside around Carlisle. Visitors can pair a stay in Carlisle with a half-day trip into Maysville for a change of pace.
Closer to town, the surrounding Nicholas County countryside invites slower exploration. Country roads wind through horse pastures, tobacco barns, and rock-bottomed creeks, and small community events and the county fair draw regional crowds during the warmer months. Within roughly an hour's drive, larger draws such as the Kentucky Horse Park and the bourbon-distillery corridors near Lexington offer easy day trips, while the Daniel Boone National Forest lies to the southeast for those interested in hiking, climbing, and backcountry scenery.
For short-term rental owners, Carlisle occupies a comfortable middle ground: small enough to feel authentic and uncrowded, yet positioned within reach of several well-established regional attractions. The combination of a memorable Revolutionary War site, a scenic Bluegrass setting, and proximity to both Lexington and the Ohio River towns gives the area a year-round appeal that rewards guests looking for a quieter base from which to explore central and northern Kentucky.