Performance indicators for the Zionsville short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Zionsville.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Zionsville permits STRs statewide but lacks clear city rules, and STRs in residential zones may be treated as prohibited Bed & Breakfasts/boarding houses, forcing costly zoning approvals (e.g., BZA special exceptions) and creating real enforcement risk (e.g., the Totty's Airbnb case). State-level licensing, insurance, and sales/innkeeper’s taxes add modest cost/complexity, and uncertain local zoning interpretation raises investor risk despite no caps or ban.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Zionsville, IN
Zionsville is a town in Boone County, Indiana, with a population of roughly 30,000 residents. Set in the rolling countryside northwest of Indianapolis, it has cultivated a refined, small-town character that contrasts with the bustle of the nearby metro. The community is best known for its picturesque downtown village, anchored by a brick-paved Main Street that draws visitors from across the Indianapolis region for its independent shops, restaurants, and walkable, tree-lined setting. Zionsville lies about 15 miles northwest of downtown Indianapolis, making it an easy commute while retaining the feel of a separate, slower-paced community.
The heart of the community is the Zionsville historic Main Street district, a walkable stretch of locally owned boutiques, coffee shops, and restaurants organized around the brick-paved street. It functions as both a gathering place for residents and a popular weekend destination for visitors from the broader Indianapolis area, with seasonal events and a steady flow of foot traffic that gives the town a noticeable sense of place.
Just southeast of town, Eagle Creek Park is one of the largest municipal parks in the United States, covering more than 3,900 acres of woods and water on the northwest edge of Indianapolis. Roughly a 20-minute drive from Zionsville, the park offers hiking trails, a large lake for paddling and sailing, a dog park, and a nature center, providing a quick nature escape without leaving the metro area.
A short drive east brings visitors to Conner Prairie, an interactive history park in Fishers that recreates 19th-century Indiana life through costumed interpreters, historic buildings, and hands-on activities. About 30 minutes from Zionsville, it is a popular family destination and one of the more distinctive history attractions in the state.
Downtown Indianapolis, roughly 25 minutes southeast, expands the range of experiences considerably. The Indianapolis Motor Speedway hosts the Indianapolis 500 each May and welcomes visitors to its museum year-round, while the Children's Museum of Indianapolis is consistently ranked among the largest and most-visited children's museums in the country. Together, these destinations give a Zionsville-based traveler a mix of small-town charm and big-city amenities within a short drive.
For short-term rental owners, Zionsville offers a compelling combination of an attractive, walkable village setting, affluent and well-maintained residential neighborhoods, and proximity to the cultural and sporting draws of Indianapolis. The town's polished character and convenient location make it appealing to visitors who want a quieter home base while remaining within easy reach of central Indiana's most-visited attractions.