Performance indicators for the Plymouth short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Plymouth.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Plymouth, IN's short‑term‑rental rules are not provided, leaving investors without clear guidance on legality, permitting fees, caps, or enforcement; this uncertainty creates a challenging regulatory environment.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Plymouth, IN
Plymouth sits in the rolling farmland and lake country of northern Indiana, serving as the seat of Marshall County. With a population of approximately 10,000 residents, the city carries the feel of a small but active county seat, offering a slower pace of life while still functioning as a regional hub for the surrounding rural communities. It is best known for hosting the annual Marshall County Blueberry Festival, one of the largest free festivals in the state, and as a gateway to the lakes, rivers, and Amish countryside of the surrounding region. Plymouth lies roughly 30 miles south of South Bend and about two hours southeast of Chicago, making it a convenient base for visitors exploring northern Indiana or traveling between larger Midwest destinations.
The lake region surrounding Marshall County draws visitors throughout the warmer months, with public access points, marinas, and quiet coves scattered around Lake Maxinkuckee and other nearby glacial lakes. Located about fifteen miles south of Plymouth near the town of Culver, Lake Maxinkuckee is one of the largest natural lakes in Indiana and offers swimming, fishing, sailing, and lakeside dining. The surrounding woodlands and the meandering Yellow River add to the outdoor appeal, giving nature lovers a peaceful counterpoint to the busier tourist corridors further north.
In South Bend, just a short drive up the road, visitors can explore the campus of the University of Notre Dame, with its iconic Golden Dome, the Basilica of the Sacred Heart, and the Snite Museum of Art. The Studebaker National Museum and the Potawatomi Zoo add to the appeal of a South Bend day trip, giving Plymouth visitors easy access to cultural and family-friendly attractions without the cost or congestion of a major metropolitan stay.
Back in Plymouth itself, the historic downtown square anchors the community, with locally owned shops, cafes, and the Marshall County Historical Museum offering a glimpse into the region's past. Each September, the Marshall County Blueberry Festival transforms the city into a bustling celebration of food, crafts, parades, and live music, drawing tens of thousands of visitors and turning the town into one of the most energetic small-city destinations in the Midwest.
Plymouth makes a compelling base for short-term rentals thanks to its blend of small-town charm, central location in northern Indiana, and proximity to both outdoor recreation and larger cultural attractions. The annual festival alone generates significant seasonal demand, while the steady flow of lake-region travelers, visiting family and friends, and weekend explorers heading to South Bend or the dunes country provides year-round potential for hosts looking to capture both weekend getaways and longer festival-driven stays.