Performance indicators for the Benton short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Benton.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Short‑term rentals are not explicitly permitted by Benton’s zoning code, placing STRs in a gray area that typically requires a zoning determination and often a special use permit; the absence of a dedicated STR ordinance, licensing, or clear path in most residential zones, combined with the need to navigate uncertain approvals, creates material compliance risk and operational barriers.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Benton, IL
Benton is a small city in southern Illinois that serves as the county seat of Franklin County, with a population of roughly 7,000 residents. It has the feel of a traditional Midwestern county seat, with a compact downtown anchored by a stately historic courthouse and a quiet, working-class character shaped by the region's long coal-mining heritage. The town sits about 90 miles southeast of St. Louis, Missouri, making it a convenient stopover or base for travelers exploring the broader Little Egypt region of southern Illinois. Benton is best known as the gateway to nearby Rend Lake and the surrounding outdoor recreation areas, drawing visitors who come for fishing, boating, hiking, and the slower pace of rural Illinois life.
Just a short drive southeast of town, Rend Lake is the area's marquee attraction and the primary reason many travelers pass through Benton. Spanning roughly 19,000 acres, the reservoir was created by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in the 1960s and offers excellent fishing for crappie, bass, and catfish, along with boating, swimming beaches, and miles of shoreline. The lake hosts several annual fishing tournaments and is a popular destination for visitors from St. Louis and across the Midwest. From downtown Benton, the main lake areas are typically reached in about 15 to 20 minutes by car.
Surrounding much of Rend Lake, the Wayne Fitzgerrell State Recreation Area provides a quieter, more nature-focused complement to the lake itself. Managed by the Illinois Department of Natural Resources, the park covers several thousand acres of woodlands and waterfront and offers campgrounds, equestrian trails, picnic areas, and hiking paths. It is a popular spot for families and outdoor enthusiasts who want to stay overnight in the area without the crowds of larger Midwestern lakes, and it sits just minutes from Benton's southern edge.
A short drive to the south brings travelers to the broader southern Illinois landscape, including the rolling hills, vineyards, and natural areas of the Shawnee Hills region. The area is dotted with state parks, wineries, and small historic towns that reward a bit of exploration, and the larger college town of Carbondale, home to Southern Illinois University, is roughly 30 to 40 miles to the southwest.
Benton makes a compelling base for short-term rental investors because it combines low operating costs and a friendly small-town atmosphere with genuine year-round appeal. Visitors come for Rend Lake fishing tournaments, family lake trips, and outdoor recreation, while the town's proximity to St. Louis and southern Illinois's broader tourism trail gives it a steady, if understated, draw. For owners, the combination of an affordable real-estate market, a recognizable regional attraction, and an authentic slice of southern Illinois hospitality makes Benton a quietly attractive option in the short-term rental space.