Performance indicators for the Arthur short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Arthur.
Loading top listings...
Very Investor friendly
Arthur, Illinois appears highly STR-friendly with no local licensing program, no prohibition, and STRs treated as permitted residential uses with standard zoning compliance. The process requires only basic building permits if needed and standard state tax registration, representing minimal regulatory burden and maximum investment opportunity.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Arthur, IL
Arthur is a small village in east-central Illinois, situated primarily in Douglas County with a small portion extending into Moultrie County. With a population of roughly 2,200 residents, the village has built a quiet reputation as one of the Midwest's most prominent Amish communities, earning it informal titles like the "Amish Capital of Illinois." Its compact downtown is lined with covered bridges, country bakeries, handcrafted furniture showrooms, and a dense concentration of antique and specialty shops, giving the town a distinctive rural and old-fashioned character that draws visitors from across the region. Arthur lies approximately 40 miles south of Champaign-Urbana and roughly 180 miles south of Chicago, putting it within easy day-trip range of several larger Midwestern population centers while retaining a peaceful, agrarian feel.
Just outside town, Rockome Gardens is a long-standing attraction that combines themed gardens, an old-time village of shops, and a working Amish farm experience. The site sits about five miles from Arthur in neighboring Arcola and offers a relaxed, family-friendly way to explore the area's Amish heritage and rural architecture. It is one of the most-visited draws in the county and pairs naturally with a stroll through Arthur's own downtown.
A short drive east of Arthur, Walnut Point State Park provides a quieter outdoor escape. Located near Oakland roughly 15 miles from the village, the park features a lake for fishing and paddling, miles of hiking trails, picnic areas, and a drive-in campground shaded by mature walnut and oak trees. It is a popular stop for travelers looking to balance browsing Arthur's shops with a few hours of nature.
About 25 miles south of Arthur, near the town of Lerna, the Lincoln Log Cabin State Historic Site preserves the final home of Abraham Lincoln's father and stepmother, along with a working 1840s-style farm. The site offers living-history demonstrations, a heritage orchard, and an interpretive center that places the Lincoln family story in the context of the small, mid-19th-century farms that once dominated this part of Illinois. It pairs well with Arthur's rural theme and adds a meaningful historical layer to a visit.
A bit farther afield, the expansive Lake Shelbyville recreation area lies roughly 35 miles south of Arthur, offering boating, fishing, swimming beaches, and miles of shoreline. With its combination of Amish heritage, antique shopping, nearby state parks, and a scattering of historical sites, Arthur offers short-term rental guests a slower-paced, distinctly Midwestern experience that remains within easy reach of several larger Illinois destinations.