Performance indicators for the Marco Island short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Marco Island.
Loading top listings...
Very Investor friendly
STRs are explicitly allowed citywide with clear state preemption and no local caps; compliance hinges on straightforward DBPR licensing and tax registration, while Marco Island’s nullified ordinance leaves investors free of city/county STR rules.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Marco Island, FL
Marco Island is a barrier-island city in Collier County on the southwest Gulf Coast of Florida, home to roughly eighteen thousand residents. With its soft white-sand beaches, warm Gulf waters, and a relaxed, resort-town atmosphere, the island is best known as an upscale beach getaway and a launching point for exploring the Ten Thousand Islands and the western reaches of the Everglades. It sits about twenty miles south of Naples and roughly an hour and a half west of Miami, making it a convenient escape for both regional weekenders and international visitors.
A first must-visit is Tigertail Beach, a wide, family-friendly stretch of sand on the island's northern end named for its early association with local wildlife. The beach offers calm Gulf swimming, a shallow lagoon popular for kayaking and paddleboarding, and a sandbar that emerges at low tide. It lies just a few minutes from most island accommodations.
Just off the main thoroughfare, the Marco Island Historical Museum traces several thousand years of local history, from the Calusa people and early pioneer settlers to the modern development of the island. The museum's exhibits on Calusa culture, who inhabited the region long before European contact, are a particular draw for visitors interested in the area's deep Indigenous heritage. It is centrally located and easy to reach from anywhere on the island.
A short drive east brings visitors to the western gateway of Everglades National Park, one of the largest subtropical wilderness areas in the United States. The park's Gulf Coast entrance, near the small town of Everglades City, is about a thirty- to forty-minute drive from Marco Island and offers ranger-led boat tours through the maze of mangrove islands known as the Ten Thousand Islands, as well as opportunities to spot manatees, dolphins, and wading birds. It is the most dramatic day trip available from the island.
North of the island, the city of Naples provides a contrasting dose of urban energy. Its historic downtown centers on Fifth Avenue South and Third Street South, where galleries, boutiques, and open-air restaurants sit just a few blocks from the municipal beach and fishing pier. Naples is roughly a twenty- to twenty-five-minute drive north over the causeway, an easy excursion for guests who want a change of pace from the island's quiet rhythm.
For short-term-rental owners, Marco Island offers an appealing combination of natural beauty, mild year-round weather, and a well-defined visitor season that peaks in the winter and spring months. The island's compact layout, walkable beach access, and proximity to both Naples and the Everglades give guests a lot to do without long drives, while its reputation as an upscale Gulf Coast destination supports steady demand. Few places in Florida pair the convenience of a small, self-contained beach town with such easy access to one of the country's most distinctive national parks, and that balance is precisely what makes the island a strong base for a vacation rental.