Performance indicators for the Big Pine Key short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Big Pine Key.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Short-term rentals are legal in Big Pine Key but only in specific zoning districts, require multiple permits and inspections, enforce a 28‑day minimum stay, and face active enforcement with fines and revocation; combined taxes at ~12.5% and moderate caps (up to 75 per district license) increase compliance burden and limit flexibility for investors.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Big Pine Key, FL
Big Pine Key sits in the Lower Florida Keys, a string of small islands curving southwest toward the southernmost point in the continental United States. The community is part of Monroe County and is home to a few thousand year-round residents, a number that swells with seasonal visitors and snowbirds each winter. The island has a relaxed, outdoorsy character, with mangrove shorelines, clear shallow water, and a quiet pace that feels far removed from mainland Florida. Big Pine Key is best known as the heart of the National Key Deer Refuge and serves as a gateway to the wildest stretch of the Lower Keys. The nearest major city is Key West, located about 30 miles to the southwest along the Overseas Highway, with a drive of roughly 45 minutes.
The most famous local attraction is the National Key Deer Refuge, which covers much of Big Pine Key and several neighboring islands. Established in 1957 to protect the tiny Key deer, an endangered subspecies found nowhere else on Earth, the refuge offers a network of short walking trails, wildlife viewing opportunities, and a visitor center with exhibits about the area's unique ecosystem. It is essentially on the island itself, with the visitor center just a few minutes from the main residential areas. Visitors can often spot Key deer along the roadsides, especially at dawn and dusk, making it a memorable stop for families and nature lovers.
Just to the west of Big Pine Key lies Bahia Honda State Park, widely regarded as one of the most beautiful state parks in Florida. The park is known for its sweeping views of the Old Bahia Honda Bridge, turquoise waters, and excellent swimming and snorkeling off a sand-and-coral beach. It is a short drive of only about 10 minutes from the center of Big Pine Key. The park's campground, beaches, and short nature trails draw visitors year-round, and it often ranks among the top destinations in the Keys for both daytime water activities and stargazing after dark.
To the southwest, the city of Key West anchors the end of the Overseas Highway and offers an entirely different experience within an easy drive. Roughly 45 minutes from Big Pine Key, Key West is famous for its colorful Old Town, sunset celebrations at Mallory Square, the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, and a lively dining and nightlife scene. Day-trippers from Big Pine Key can easily enjoy Key West's historic core, then return to the quieter, more natural setting of the Lower Keys for the evening.
For travelers looking to base themselves in the Lower Keys, Big Pine Key offers a compelling mix of seclusion and accessibility. Its location between the natural attractions of the Keys' western reaches and the cultural and culinary offerings of Key West makes it ideal for guests who want both quiet waterfront mornings and full days of exploration. The island's vacation rentals cater to nature lovers, anglers, and families drawn by the surrounding waters, and the steady flow of visitors to nearby Bahia Honda and Key West helps support year-round demand for short-term stays.