Performance indicators for the Madison short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Madison.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Legality remains contested and no ordinance is in place yet, creating enforcement inconsistency while a future rulemaking is expected to impose registration/permits, caps, and restrictions within 6–24 months; this legal and regulatory uncertainty elevates risk despite many listings operating today.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Madison, CT
Madison is a coastal town in New Haven County, Connecticut, with a population of approximately 18,000 residents. The town has a classic New England character, blending a walkable historic downtown with a scenic stretch of Long Island Sound shoreline. It is best known for its beaches and as the home of one of Connecticut's most popular state parks, and it serves as a gateway to a string of equally charming shoreline communities along the central Connecticut coast. Madison sits about 20 miles northeast of New Haven, the nearest major city, and roughly 90 miles from New York City, putting it within easy reach of two of the largest population centers in the Northeast.
Hammonasset Beach State Park is the marquee draw in Madison and one of the most visited outdoor destinations in the state. Stretching along more than two miles of Long Island Sound beach, the park offers swimming, fishing, camping, and a network of walking and biking trails through salt marshes and along Meigs Point. It is just minutes from the town center, and the official state parks page offers a detailed overview of amenities and seasonal information: Hammonasset Beach State Park.
Downtown Madison centers around the Boston Post Road and the adjacent historic district, where 19th-century architecture houses a mix of independent boutiques, restaurants, and cafés. The tree-lined streets and well-preserved homes give the area a low-key, residential feel that contrasts with the busier shoreline towns farther west. Visitors and residents alike gravitate here for casual dining and seasonal events throughout the year.
Just east of Madison lies the town of Guilford, another historic shoreline community known for its sprawling town green — one of the largest in New England — surrounded by colonial-era homes, churches, and the Henry Whitfield State Museum, the oldest stone house in New England. The drive from Madison to Guilford's center takes about 10 minutes, making it an easy pairing for a day of exploring.
Farther afield, the lower Connecticut River Valley offers additional opportunities for day trips. The towns of Essex, Chester, and Old Saybrook sit within roughly 20 to 30 minutes of Madison by car, each known for riverfront scenery, antique shops, and small museums. Old Lyme, a bit farther east, is recognized as the birthplace of American Impressionism and remains home to the Florence Griswold Museum, the former boardinghouse of the Lyme Art Colony.
Madison's combination of accessible shoreline, small-town atmosphere, and proximity to both New Haven and the greater New York metropolitan area makes it a natural fit for short-term rentals. Travelers seeking a quieter coastal alternative to the Hamptons or Cape Cod find a town that delivers beaches, historic character, and convenient access to a chain of equally charming Connecticut shore communities — all within an easy drive of major Northeast population centers.