Performance indicators for the Red Feather Lakes short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Red Feather Lakes.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are allowed countywide but Red Feather Lakes has a 250-foot separation requirement and many costly/complex steps (pre-app, 60-day referral, detailed submittals, life-safety inspections, and high fees up to $1,000). Strict enforcement (3 strikes, neighbor notifications) and operational mandates (24/7 manager within 1 hour) create notable compliance burden and investment risk.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Red Feather Lakes, CO
Red Feather Lakes is a small unincorporated mountain community in Larimer County, Colorado, nestled at roughly 8,400 feet in the Roosevelt National Forest. With a year-round population of only a few hundred residents, it has the feel of a rustic mountain village, a place of ponderosa pines, small general stores, and a scattering of cabins and lodges clustered around the namesake chain of lakes. The community is best known as a year-round outdoor recreation hub and as a quiet gateway to the Cache la Poudre corridor, one of the wildest sections of the Colorado Rockies. It sits about 50 miles northwest of Fort Collins and roughly 100 miles north of Denver, tucked far enough into the mountains to feel remote but close enough to Front Range population centers to remain a workable weekend escape.
Just outside the village, the Roosevelt National Forest wraps around Red Feather Lakes in every direction, offering immediate access to hiking, mountain biking, horseback riding, and snowmobiling. The surrounding forest lands include marked trails, scenic byways, and dispersed camping areas, all within a short drive of the village center, making the national forest itself a primary draw for visitors who come for the wilderness rather than a single landmark.
To the south and east of town, the Cache la Poudre River corridor carves a dramatic canyon through the mountains. Designated as a National Wild and Scenic River, the Cache la Poudre River is renowned for whitewater rafting, fly fishing, and a scenic drive that climbs upstream into the Poudre Canyon. The drive from Red Feather Lakes to the lower canyon takes roughly an hour, and the river draws outdoor enthusiasts from across the region throughout the warmer months.
Within the community itself, the cluster of high-elevation lakes is the namesake feature, and the surrounding area is dotted with additional draws such as the Shambhala Mountain Center, a Buddhist meditation retreat set on a large wooded property, as well as trail systems that connect the village to nearby peaks and meadows. The village also hosts an annual library fundraiser, a summer concert series, and a handful of locally owned restaurants and outfitters that cater to visitors rather than through-traffic, giving the place a lived-in, community-oriented character despite its small size.
For short-term rental owners, Red Feather Lakes offers an appealing combination of natural setting, established tourist infrastructure, and relative scarcity of lodging, which keeps demand steady for cabins and larger homes. Visitors drawn to national forest access, the Poudre corridor, and the area's alpine quiet tend to stay multiple nights, and the proximity to both Fort Collins and the northern Front Range gives the market a reliable base of regional guests looking for a genuine mountain getaway.