Performance indicators for the Peyton short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Peyton.
Loading top listings...
Very Investor friendly
Short‑term rentals are permitted in most of Peyton via unincorporated El Paso County with no county permit or caps; only accessory structures require zoning approval. Inside Colorado Springs, permits are straightforward ($124.95), and while non‑owner‑occupied units face density and zoning limits, there is no citywide cap and the process is well‑defined. Overall, the rules are permissive, compliance is manageable, and the tone is investor‑friendly.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Peyton, CO
Peyton is an unincorporated community in El Paso County, Colorado, situated on the high plains roughly twenty miles northeast of Colorado Springs. With a small population of approximately 1,000 residents, it functions as a quiet rural community in the transition zone where the Front Range urban corridor gives way to the wide eastern plains. The area is characterized by large-lot residential properties, horse ranches, and open vistas, lending it a distinctly country character despite its proximity to the Colorado Springs metropolitan area. Peyton itself is not a major tourist draw, but its location makes it a practical base for travelers exploring the Pikes Peak region and the surrounding prairie landscapes.
One of the most distinctive natural attractions near Peyton is the Paint Mines Interpretive Park, a remarkable geological site featuring vividly colored clay and rock formations in shades of white, yellow, orange, and purple. The park offers roughly four miles of trails winding through hoodoos, spires, and eroded gullies, and archaeological evidence suggests it has been used by humans for thousands of years. Located only about five to ten miles southeast of Peyton, it is a popular destination for hikers, photographers, and families seeking an easy outdoor outing.
Roughly twenty to thirty minutes southwest of Peyton lies Colorado Springs, a city of around 480,000 residents that anchors the region's tourism economy. The city offers easy access to Garden of the Gods, a registered National Natural Landmark with towering red sandstone formations set against a backdrop of snowcapped peaks. Garden of the Gods draws visitors from around the world for its dramatic scenery, rock climbing, and miles of paved and unpaved trails.
Just west of Colorado Springs stands Pikes Peak, one of Colorado's most famous fourteeners, rising to more than 14,000 feet. Travelers can reach the summit via the Pikes Peak Highway, the historic cog railway from Manitou Springs, or by hiking one of the mountain's many trails. From Peyton, the journey to the base of Pikes Peak or to Manitou Springs is roughly forty to sixty minutes, depending on the destination within the foothills.
For those drawn to the prairie, the open grasslands of eastern El Paso County and the surrounding plains begin just beyond Peyton's edge. The community's position at the rural-urban interface gives it a unique appeal for travelers who want to experience both the high plains and the mountain scenery of central Colorado without committing to a single setting. Visitors can spend mornings watching sunrises over unbroken prairie and afternoons exploring mountain parks and geological wonders, all within an easy day's outing.
Peyton offers short-term rental operators a compelling niche: a peaceful, rural setting with genuine dark skies, room to roam, and a country feel, yet well within reach of one of Colorado's most visited regions. Guests can return each evening to quiet surroundings away from the bustle of downtown Colorado Springs, while still enjoying convenient access to iconic attractions like Garden of the Gods, Pikes Peak, and the Paint Mines. The combination of rural charm, regional access, and proximity to natural wonders makes Peyton an attractive alternative for travelers seeking a more grounded Colorado experience.