Performance indicators for the Oak Creek short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Oak Creek.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Oak Creek allows STRs but imposes extremely restrictive caps (only 15 total permits town-wide), requires primary residence status, and mandates multiple complex operational plans (parking, fire safety, snow removal) for annual licensing. The combination of strict zoning limitations, scarcity of permits, and high compliance burden creates significant barriers that would challenge potential investors despite the technically legal status.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Oak Creek, CO
Oak Creek is a small town tucked into the Yampa Valley of Routt County, in northwestern Colorado, with a population of roughly 900 residents. It has the feel of a quiet former ranching and coal-mining community that has gradually shifted its rhythm toward outdoor recreation and tourism, sitting alongside the Yampa River and the forested hills that frame the valley. The town is best known as a gateway to Stagecoach State Park and as a quieter, more affordable alternative for visitors heading into the Steamboat Springs area. Denver, the nearest major city, lies roughly 150 miles to the southeast, while Steamboat Springs is only about 17 miles to the north along US Highway 131.
Just a few miles south of town, Stagecoach State Park wraps around a 1,600-acre reservoir that draws visitors for boating, fishing, paddleboarding, and camping in the warmer months. The park also includes a network of mountain biking and hiking trails on the surrounding slopes, and in winter it operates as a Nordic ski area, giving Oak Creek a year-round reason for travelers to stop. The short drive from the center of town makes it a natural fit for day trips and weekend stays.
A little farther north, the city of Steamboat Springs anchors the region as one of Colorado's most famous ski destinations, with the Steamboat Ski Resort's wide, family-friendly runs and its natural Strawberry Park Hot Springs drawing visitors in every season. The drive from Oak Creek to downtown Steamboat is about 25 minutes, which positions the town as a convenient base for guests who want to enjoy the resort and hot springs without paying resort-area prices. Downtown Steamboat also offers a walkable core of restaurants, galleries, and Western-style storefronts that complement the area's ranching heritage.
To the south and east, the Routt National Forest spreads across the surrounding mountains, offering access to hiking, horseback riding, hunting, and snowmobiling on an extensive trail system. The forest connects to the larger Medicine Bow–Routt landscape that runs toward the Wyoming border, meaning Oak Creek sits within easy reach of some of the most expansive backcountry in the southern Rockies. Closer to town, the Oak Creek Canyon area provides a scenic drive with opportunities for fishing along the Yampa River and its tributaries.
Oak Creek appeals to short-term-rental owners because it combines the small-town atmosphere of an authentic Colorado mountain community with direct access to Steamboat Springs' resort amenities, a state park with four-season recreation, and a vast national forest for outdoor adventure. Guests who stay here can enjoy a quieter setting at a lower price point while still being within a short drive of some of northwestern Colorado's biggest draws, making the town a flexible and well-located base for year-round bookings.