Performance indicators for the Hartsel short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Hartsel.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs are explicitly allowed without caps on the number of licenses or rental nights, and enforcement appears consistent, but investors face moderate permitting costs and complexity (non-refundable $605 fee, extensive documentation, safety inspections for older properties, and detailed operational plans).
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Hartsel, CO
Hartsel is a tiny, wide-open unincorporated community in Park County, Colorado, often called "The Heart of South Park" for its location in the high-altitude South Park basin. With a resident population of only around 100 people, Hartsel is less a town than a historical crossroads ranching settlement, sitting where U.S. Highway 24 meets State Highway 9. The community has a quiet, frontier-era feel, with expansive mountain vistas, big skies, and a pace of life shaped by the surrounding cattle ranches and alpine wilderness. It serves as a natural gateway to some of central Colorado's most prized reservoirs, fishing waters, and high-country trails, and is roughly 60 to 70 miles southeast of the nearest major city, Colorado Springs, with Denver sitting about 90 miles or so to the northeast.
Just northeast of Hartsel, Eleven Mile State Park is one of the area's biggest draws, only about a 15-minute drive from town. The park wraps around a large reservoir popular for trout and kokanee salmon fishing, sailing, and windsurfing, and its shoreline is dotted with campgrounds and picnic spots that attract visitors year-round. Birders also come for the chance to spot bald eagles and other raptors around the lake's edges.
Even closer to Hartsel, just a few miles to the north along Highway 9, Spinney Mountain State Park offers another stretch of reservoir and Gold Medal trout waters set against the backdrop of the South Park hills. The park is prized for its quiet, less-crowded fishing, as well as for the wildlife that frequents its meadows and shoreline, and it provides a peaceful complement to busier destinations elsewhere in the Rockies.
About 20 miles north of Hartsel, the small town of Fairplay hosts South Park City, an open-air museum complex of more than forty preserved buildings recreating an 1880s-era Colorado mining town, complete with a schoolhouse, saloon, blacksmith shop, and assayer's office. The site is a popular stop for visitors exploring the region and offers a tangible sense of the boom-and-bust mining heritage that shaped Park County.
Roughly 30 to 40 miles north of Hartsel along Highway 9, Breckenridge opens up a completely different side of the mountains, with a historic Victorian-era downtown, summer hiking and mountain biking, and one of Colorado's most visited ski resorts in the winter. Together, the combination of reservoir recreation, ranching-country atmosphere, and easy access to both high-country quiet and busy resort amenities makes Hartsel a versatile base for travelers passing through or settling in for a longer stay. For short-term-rental owners, that mix of year-round outdoor appeal and proximity to well-known Front Range population centers gives the community a steady, varied visitor base without the bustle of the resort towns themselves.