Performance indicators for the Sutter Creek short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Sutter Creek.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are technically allowed but require a discretionary Conditional Use Permit for each property with a public hearing, non‑transferable permits, and a 24/7 response mandate plus three dedicated off‑street parking spaces—creating uncertainty and added cost/operations burden.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Sutter Creek, CA
Sutter Creek is a small Gold Country city of roughly 2,500 residents in Amador County, California, tucked into the western foothills of the Sierra Nevada. It sits about 45 miles southeast of Sacramento, the nearest major city, and serves as a gateway to the historic Mother Lode, the Amador County wine region, and a string of well-preserved Gold Rush towns. Its compact, walkable downtown along Main Street forms the heart of the community, and the city is best known for its preserved 19th-century architecture, its gold-mining heritage, and the antique shops, tasting rooms, and small restaurants that line the historic district.
About fifteen minutes east of Sutter Creek, near the community of Pine Grove, lies Indian Grinding Rock State Historic Park, one of the most significant Native American sites in the Sierra foothills. The park protects a massive limestone outcrop bearing more than a thousand bedrock mortar holes, along with a reconstructed Miwok village and a small museum focused on regional indigenous history. It is a frequent stop for visitors exploring Gold Country and draws hikers, campers, and families throughout the year.
A short drive farther east brings travelers to Black Chasm Cavern, a National Natural Landmark in the tiny town of Volcano. The cavern is known for its remarkably preserved helictite formations — delicate, twisting crystal structures found in very few caves worldwide — and offers guided walking tours that descend roughly eighty feet below the surface. It is one of the few show caves in the Mother Lode and tends to be popular with families and geology enthusiasts on a hot foothill afternoon.
The Shenandoah Valley and other Amador County wine-growing pockets lie roughly twenty to thirty minutes south of Sutter Creek, where the high-elevation climate and decomposed granite soils have made the region a respected source of old-vine Zinfandel. Dozens of small family-owned tasting rooms are scattered along winding back roads, often with picnic tables and views of the surrounding oak-studded hills. The wine country complements the town's historic appeal and gives visitors a relaxed, scenic counterpoint to the mining-era sights.
Sutter Creek's blend of small-town charm, walkable historic core, and proximity to a remarkable cluster of Gold Country attractions — state parks, caverns, neighboring mining towns, and a respected wine region — makes it a strong base for short-term-rental guests. Travelers can spend their days exploring the Mother Lode and return in the evening to a quiet, photogenic downtown with restaurants and tasting rooms within easy walking distance, all within roughly an hour of Sacramento and the Bay Area beyond.