Performance indicators for the Mckinleyville short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Mckinleyville.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are explicitly allowed but constrained by a 2% cap (also 2% within the McKinleyville plan area) and strict coastal rules (one STR per parcel, 10% street concentration, private gatherings prohibited). The two‑year permitting and renewal process, along with health/safety, Good Neighbor, noise/parking standards, create compliance and enforcement risk that dampens investor friendliness.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Mckinleyville, CA
McKinleyville is an unincorporated community of roughly 15,000 residents on California's remote North Coast, situated in Humboldt County between the college town of Arcata to the south and the small harbor village of Trinidad to the north. Set among stands of coast redwood, dairy pasture, and windswept Pacific beaches, it has the relaxed, outdoorsy character typical of the region, with a modest commercial corridor along U.S. Highway 101 serving as the main hub between those two neighbors. McKinleyville functions primarily as a gateway community for travelers heading to Redwood National and State Parks and the wider redwood coast. It lies about 280 miles north of San Francisco, a drive of roughly five to six hours, and a little farther north of Sacramento.
Just up the highway from McKinleyville, the small harbor town of Trinidad offers a distinctly Northern California coastal experience in a compact footprint. Roughly a 10- to 15-minute drive north on Highway 101, the town has a working fishing harbor, Trinidad State Beach, a lighthouse, and a handful of seafood spots, and it serves as the southern staging ground for visitors exploring the redwoods and rocky coastline of the Trinidad area. A short distance beyond Trinidad, Sue-meg State Park (formerly Patrick's Point State Park) is about a 20- to 25-minute drive from McKinleyville. The park features rugged cliffs, tide pools, ceremonial Yurok sites including a reconstructed Sumeg village, and several miles of hiking trails winding through spruce and redwood groves down to the surf.
Redwood National and State Parks form the marquee draw of the entire region, and McKinleyville is one of the most convenient bases for exploring them. The park complex's southern units, including the Lady Bird Johnson Grove and the visitor center at Kuchel, are roughly 20 to 45 minutes north of town, while the larger system extends more than an hour farther north along the coast and the Smith River. Visitors come for the old-growth coast redwood groves, herds of Roosevelt elk in the prairie meadows, and quiet beaches such as Gold Bluffs and Crescent.
Within McKinleyville itself, Clam Beach County Park stretches along the ocean just west of town and is a popular spot for surfing, beach walking, and sunset views, while the Hammond Trail, a paved multi-use path converted from a former railroad grade, runs through the community and connects to a longer regional trail system favored by cyclists and joggers. A short drive south, Arcata and the larger city of Eureka add a wider selection of restaurants, breweries, Victorian architecture, and the campus of Cal Poly Humboldt.
McKinleyville's appeal for short-term rentals lies in its position as a quieter, more affordable alternative to Arcata or Eureka while still being within easy reach of the redwoods, the coast, and the small-town attractions of Trinidad. Its highway-front setting, calm residential streets, and proximity to the region's most visited natural landmarks make it a natural fit for travelers planning outdoor-focused trips to California's North Coast.