Performance indicators for the Saint Johns short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Saint Johns.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs appear to be permitted under general residential zoning with standard municipal business licensing, fire/building inspections, and state tax registration, and there are no explicit caps or restrictive rules noted. The main challenge is regulatory ambiguity, as no STR‑specific ordinance exists and zoning confirmation is required before operations, but compliance steps are manageable. Investor risk remains moderate due to the need for verification and potential future rules.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Saint Johns, AZ
Saint Johns is a small, quiet town that serves as the county seat of Apache County in eastern Arizona. With a population of roughly 3,300 residents, it carries the unhurried pace of a traditional ranching and farming community, surrounded by high desert grasslands and the distant forested mountains of the Apache-Sitgreaves. The town has a long history as one of the older European-settled places in this part of the state, and it functions today as a modest regional hub for the surrounding rural area, including the nearby White Mountains region. It sits roughly 200 miles east of Phoenix, or about a three-and-a-half-hour drive, and approximately 170 miles southeast of Flagstaff, making it a natural overnight stop for travelers moving between the Phoenix metro area, the high country, and the eastern borderlands.
A short drive south of town, Lyman Lake State Park draws visitors with its reservoir, sandy beaches, and canyon-rim scenery. The lake is well known locally for fishing — including trout, bass, and catfish — as well as for boating, swimming, and waterside camping, and the surrounding terrain has long been a favorite of stargazers. It is roughly fifteen to twenty miles from Saint Johns along a quiet country road, which makes it especially convenient for a day trip or a relaxed evening on the water.
To the northwest, the much larger draw is Petrified Forest National Park, a nationally known destination of colorful badlands, scattered fragments of ancient petrified wood, petroglyphs, and the sweeping vistas of the Painted Desert. The park's main entrance off Interstate 40 near Holbrook is a little over an hour's drive from Saint Johns, putting the small town in reach of one of the more unusual landscapes in the American Southwest.
South and west of Saint Johns lies the White Mountains of Arizona, a high-country recreation area built around the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests. The region offers fishing on cool mountain lakes, hiking through ponderosa pine forests, and winter access to the Sunrise Park Resort ski area near Greer, which sits roughly seventy miles from Saint Johns through a scenic drive over the Mogollon Rim country.
For a short-term-rental investor, Saint Johns appeals because of its position at the intersection of several very different travel patterns: long-haul road trippers crossing Arizona on Interstate 40, outdoor enthusiasts heading into the White Mountains, and visitors making day trips to Lyman Lake and the Petrified Forest. The town has the low-key character of a rural county seat, the kind of place where visitors genuinely feel they have stepped off the main highway and into a working Arizona community, while still being close enough to marquee destinations to make a stay here feel like a well-placed base rather than a detour.