Performance indicators for the Payson short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Payson.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
Payson allows STRs citywide with explicit licenses and has no occupancy or unit caps. Fees are moderate ($250 town license; $225 county permit) but multi‑jurisdictional licensing, fire inspection, insurance, commercial trash, background checks, and detailed neighbor/online disclosures add cost/complexity. The process is clear, consistent, and enforcement‑oriented, which supports investment but is not as light‑touch as a pure A.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Payson, AZ
Payson is a small mountain town in Gila County, Arizona, with an approximate population of around 16,000 residents. Perched at roughly 5,000 feet of elevation along the Mogollon Rim country of central Arizona, the town carries a laid-back, outdoorsy character that draws visitors looking to escape the desert heat of the lower Sonoran valleys. It is widely known as a gateway to the Tonto National Forest and the higher pine country of the Rim, and it is often celebrated for hosting one of the oldest continuous rodeos in the country. Payson sits about 90 miles north of Phoenix, an easy drive of roughly 90 minutes to two hours depending on traffic and route, which makes it a popular weekend escape for residents of the Phoenix metro area.
One of the most distinctive nearby attractions is Tonto Natural Bridge State Park, believed to be the largest natural travertine bridge in the world. The park, located just north of Payson, offers a short and scenic drive of roughly fifteen to twenty minutes, with hiking trails that wind down into the pine-filled canyon beneath the massive stone arch. Visitors can also stop by the small on-site museum and lodge area to learn about the geology and history of the formation. The park is a popular day trip for both families and outdoor enthusiasts and is one of the defining landmarks of the Payson region.
Just outside of town, the Tonto National Forest surrounds Payson on nearly every side, providing nearly three million acres of public land for hiking, camping, fishing, and off-roading. The forest's Payson Ranger District is one of the busiest in the national forest system, thanks to its proximity to Phoenix and its diverse mix of desert, chaparral, and pine-fir landscapes. Visitors can drive just minutes from downtown to find trailheads, cool pine-shaded campgrounds, and several reservoirs popular for fishing and boating.
A short drive north of Payson, the Mogollon Rim rises dramatically above the town, offering some of the most sweeping overlooks in Arizona. This 200-mile-long escarpment marks the southern edge of the Colorado Plateau and provides access to cooler temperatures, dense ponderosa pine forests, and a network of trails and lakes. Payson itself hosts the annual Rim Country Festival, a longstanding community event that celebrates the regional heritage and outdoor lifestyle, and the Green Valley Park in the heart of town offers a small lake, walking paths, and event spaces that draw both locals and visitors.
Payson makes a compelling base for short-term rentals because it combines small-town character with direct access to some of Arizona's most rewarding outdoor destinations. Guests can spend a morning hiking under a natural stone arch, an afternoon fishing on a forest reservoir, and an evening enjoying a local restaurant or rodeo, all within a couple of hours' drive of the Phoenix metro area. This blend of accessibility, natural beauty, and a slower pace of life gives the town a year-round appeal that translates well into the vacation rental market.