Performance indicators for the Penn Yan short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Penn Yan.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are allowed citywide as a conditional special use but require two costly, multi‑step approvals (STR permit and special use permit), SEQR environmental review, site plan and floor plans, and mandatory inspections plus annual renewals; fees are tiered up to $2,500 for non‑residents with only modest renewal fees; a local 24/7 manager, strict occupancy/parking limits, detailed advertising/operational rules, and ongoing fire/maintenance inspections create meaningful compliance burden, while the village appears supportive but rigorous, pushing risk into the higher‑end of challenging.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Penn Yan, NY
Penn Yan is a small village in Yates County, in the heart of New York's Finger Lakes region, with a population of approximately 5,000 residents. The unusual name is a contraction of two of the area's early settlers, James Penn and Jonathan Yaney, and the village sits at the northern tip of Keuka Lake, one of the most distinctive of the eleven Finger Lakes thanks to its branched, Y-shaped outline. Penn Yan serves as a quiet, walkable base for exploring the surrounding wine country, lake scenery, and small-town charm, and lies roughly 50 miles south of Rochester, the nearest major city.
Keuka Lake is the central draw for visitors to Penn Yan. Often nicknamed the "Crooked Lake" for its branched shape, it offers swimming, kayaking, fishing, and a shoreline dotted with vineyards and tasting rooms. Public access points are scattered around the lake, and the village's lakeside edges connect directly to the scenery.
Keuka Lake State Park sits on the lake's western shore a few miles south of the village and provides picnic areas, a boat launch, a swimming beach, and camping. It is one of the most accessible state-park gateways to the lake and a popular spot for visitors who want an easy day by the water.
At the lake's opposite tip, the village of Hammondsport is a short drive south and is widely known as the "Cradle of Aviation" in honor of aviation pioneer Glenn Curtiss. The town has a preserved historic main street, the Glenn H. Curtiss Museum, and additional wineries tucked into the surrounding hills.
Further afield, Watkins Glen State Park — famous for its stone-walled gorge trail, waterfalls, and cascading stream — lies roughly 25 miles south along the western edge of Seneca Lake. Visitors can combine a Penn Yan stay with a day trip to the gorge and the village of Watkins Glen, which sits at the southern end of Seneca Lake and is known for its harbor, racetrack, and salt-dock shops.
Penn Yan works well as a short-term rental market because it offers the amenities of a compact, walkable village — restaurants, shops, a farmers' market, and a working lakeside — while placing guests within easy reach of Keuka Lake, the broader Finger Lakes wine trail, historic small towns, and iconic state-park scenery. Its year-round mix of summer lake activities, fall foliage, and winter sports makes it a flexible base for travelers exploring the region.