Performance indicators for the Montgomery short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Montgomery.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
Montgomery permits STRs but only on single-family homes in residential districts with lots ≥2 acres and a 2-year, revocable permit requiring inspections, insurance, septic/water testing, signage limits, and neighbor notification. Operability is constrained by safety and utility standards, an occupancy cap (≤10, ≤2/bedroom, with tighter septic limits), and clear enforcement powers with fines; however, STRs remain a viable, known compliance process rather than a de facto prohibition.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Montgomery, NY
Montgomery is a town in Orange County, New York, situated in the lower Hudson Valley roughly sixty miles north of New York City. With a population of approximately twenty-three thousand, the town encompasses a historic village core surrounded by rolling farmland, orchards, and the wooded slopes of the surrounding ridges. It serves as a convenient base for travelers exploring the Hudson Valley's wineries, outdoor recreation, and cultural landmarks, and is often used as a gateway to the Shawangunk Ridge and the broader Orange County region.
Just outside Montgomery, in the neighboring town of Washingtonville, Brotherhood Winery claims the title of America's oldest operating winery, with roots reaching back to 1839. Visitors can tour the historic underground cellars, sample vintages in the tasting room, and explore the manicured grounds, all within roughly ten minutes of the village center.
A short drive south brings travelers to Storm King Art Center, a sprawling five-hundred-acre outdoor sculpture park set against the dramatic backdrop of Storm King Mountain in the Hudson Highlands. About twenty-five minutes from Montgomery, the center features monumental works by artists such as Alexander Calder, Mark di Suvero, and Maya Lin, and is widely regarded as one of the premier sculpture parks in the country.
Shoppers will find the renowned Woodbury Common Premium Outlets in Central Valley, roughly ten to fifteen minutes from Montgomery. With hundreds of stores spread across a vast open-air campus, the outlet center draws visitors from across the New York metropolitan area and beyond, making it one of the most-visited retail destinations in the region.
For outdoor enthusiasts, the Shawangunk Ridge and Minnewaska State Park Preserve lie about thirty to forty minutes west of Montgomery. The ridge is renowned among rock climbers for its white conglomerate cliffs, while the park preserve offers miles of carriage roads, sky lakes, waterfalls, and sweeping views of the Catskills and Hudson Valley — a draw in every season.
With its central position in Orange County, its proximity to the New York metropolitan area, and its easy access to wineries, cultural landmarks, outlet shopping, and some of the Northeast's most celebrated outdoor landscapes, Montgomery offers a versatile foundation for short-term rental guests. The town's blend of small-village character and regional connectivity makes it well suited to travelers seeking a quieter Hudson Valley home base without sacrificing convenience to the area's marquee destinations.